Subjects = Security Studies
Number of Articles: 157
<span>The Dialectic of Sharia and Security: Security in the Political Jurisprudence of Kashif al-Ghita</span>

The Dialectic of Sharia and Security: Security in the Political Jurisprudence of Kashif al-Ghita

Volume 29, Issue 1, Summer 2026, Pages 11-39

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2026.584180.4384

Hossein Hamzeh

Abstract Introduction Security is a fundamental human need, and every normative system conceptualizes it in accordance with its own values and objectives. In Imami Shi'a jurisprudence, security is not treated as a distinct legal category. Rather, its various dimensions are addressed through concepts such as defensive jihad, preservation of the integrity of Islam, repelling aggression, maintaining social order, and protecting religious rites. Understanding the significance of security in the works of early Shi'a jurists therefore requires reconstructing the relationship among these concepts. To understand the significance of this issue in the political jurisprudence of Shaykh Ja'far Kashif al-Ghita, it is necessary to consider the historical context of his time. At the beginning of the thirteenth century AH (late eighteenth century CE), Shi'a communities faced two distinct forms of threat: incursions by the Russian Empire, which endangered Islamic territories and Muslim lives, and Wahhabi attacks on the Shi'a holy cities, which combined threats to religious and communal identity with physical insecurity. Although Kashif al-Ghita did not regard the Qajar monarchy as inherently legitimate, he authorized Fath-Ali Shah to mobilize forces for the defense of Islamic territories. This raises a fundamental question: How did his jurisprudence permit the use of the ruler's political and military capacities for the fulfillment of the duty of defense without conferring inherent legitimacy on the monarchy? The central research question is: How can the security logic of Kashif al-Ghita's political jurisprudence be reconstructed through his jurisprudential concepts and rulings, and what mechanism does his thought provide for regulating the relationship among Sharia, political authority, and active defense in response to threats? The study argues that the central concept underlying this security logic is “preserving the integrity of Islam” (hifz-e bayza-ye Islam). When a serious threat emerges, Sharia activates its protective functions through rulings concerning defensive jihad, the protection of religious rites, and the granting of limited authorization to political authority. Security, therefore, is not externally imposed on Sharia; rather, the presence of a threat elevates its significance as a jurisprudential principle and brings it to the forefront. Methodology The study employs a descriptive-analytical approach based on a close reading of Kashif al-Ghita's Kashf al-Ghita and his treatises on jihad, with particular attention to the historical context in which his views were articulated. To avoid conceptual anachronism, the study distinguishes between the jurist's own terminology and the analytical concepts used to interpret his thought. The theoretical framework consists of three levels: Islamic political philosophy, which views security as a condition for the possibility of collective social life; jurisprudence, which translates this foundation into the normative objective of “preservation”; and the question of the “referent of security,” through which concepts such as the preservation of the integrity of Islam and dar al-Islam (lands under Islamic rule) are identified as the principal objects of protection. Findings and Discussion The referent of security. In Kashif al-Ghita's political jurisprudence, security cannot be reduced to the ruler or the state. His ruling on jihad against Russia was not intended to defend the ruler personally, but was justified in terms of preserving Islam. The primary referent of security is the “foundation of Islam,” a fundamental entity on which the survival of religion, social order, territorial frontiers, and religious rites depends. This referent encompasses several interconnected levels: the integrity of Islam, dar al-Islam, the Muslim community, and religious rites. Addressing military threats. In Kashif al-Ghita's jurisprudence, confronting military threats constitutes a religious obligation under the category of defensive jihad. A distinctive feature of his jurisprudence is what this study conceptualizes as “delegated security authority.” When a jurist lacks the material means necessary to exercise political and military power, he may authorize a capable ruler to undertake the practical task of providing security. By granting religious authorization to Fath-Ali Shah, Kashif al-Ghita placed the ruler in the position of an agent responsible for organizing defense. The Qajar monarch was therefore neither the referent of security nor the source of the legitimacy of defense. Rather, he functioned as an executive authority acting under the jurist's authorization. Addressing intellectual and religious threats. In Kashif al-Ghita's thought, threats are not limited to physical aggression. Any development that undermines the intellectual and religious cohesion of the Muslim community may constitute a broader security threat. Insults against the Prophet Muhammad, because of their potentially disruptive impact on the foundations of the religious community, give rise to a collective obligation and require Muslims to respond to them. The dialectic of Sharia and security. The “dialectic of Sharia and security” in this context does not imply a conflict or contradiction between security and the requirements of Sharia. Within Kashif al-Ghita's jurisprudential framework, security is not introduced as an external, non-religious interest. Rather, it is derived from concepts such as protecting the integrity of Islam and defending the frontiers of dar al-Islam. This relationship operates through two mechanisms: changes in legal rulings resulting from changes in the subject matter, and the principle that more important legal considerations take precedence in times of crisis. Conclusion The central finding of the study is that the “referent of security” in Kashif al-Ghita's political jurisprudence is neither the monarchy nor the state, but the foundation and integrity of Islam. His ruling on jihad against Russia should therefore be understood not as an endorsement of Qajar rule, but as a religiously grounded defense of the frontiers of dar al-Islam. An examination of the concept of “authorized monarchy” (saltanat-e ma'zun) shows that Kashif al-Ghita distinguished between the inherent legitimacy of political authority and the functional authorization granted to an existing ruler. His authorization of the Qajar monarch did not amount to an absolute legitimation of the monarchy. Rather, it constituted a limited authorization to organize and conduct defensive action. From this perspective, security in Kashif al-Ghita's thought does not represent a departure from Sharia. Instead, it constitutes an important domain through which the objectives of Sharia become operative in protecting Islam and the Muslim community.

Opposition and the Reproduction of Domination in the Global South: A Comparative Case Study of Iran and Venezuela

Opposition and the Reproduction of Domination in the Global South: A Comparative Case Study of Iran and Venezuela

Volume 29, Issue 1, Summer 2026, Pages 127-159

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2026.567635.4348

Ali Davari, Seyyed Javad Hosseini

Abstract Introduction In the political science literature, opposition is generally conceptualized as an endogenous political force that emerges from civil society and serves either to promote political reform or to constrain those in power. This understanding is rooted largely in the historical experience of liberal nation-states in the Global North and has often been extended to societies in the Global South without sufficient attention to their distinct historical, political, and structural contexts. Applying the concept of opposition to the Global South without accounting for structural inequalities in the international distribution of power, however, raises important analytical challenges. Many countries in the Global South, particularly those subject to geopolitical confrontation, economic sanctions, political pressure, and external intervention, operate within a broader environment shaped by economic, financial, media, and security pressures exerted by dominant global powers. Under such circumstances, the boundary between autonomous political action and political activity facilitated or supported by external actors can become blurred. This study is significant because overlooking the distinction between endogenous opposition and opposition aligned with dominant powers can lead to misinterpretations of political developments in the Global South and, consequently, to the formulation of misguided security strategies. The central research question is whether opposition groups in the Global South invariably play an endogenous and emancipatory role or whether, in some contexts, they can become instruments through which structures of global domination are reproduced. The paper hypothesizes that, in some cases, particularly in countries engaged in strategic confrontation with dominant powers, opposition groups may reinforce rather than challenge structures of global domination. Through external institutional and financial ties, support for economic sanctions, and the acceptance or normalization of external pressure and military intervention, such groups may contribute to the reproduction of global structures of domination. Methodology This study employs a qualitative research approach and a comparative case-study design. Iran and Venezuela were purposively selected as cases of Global South states that have, in recent decades, been engaged in sustained strategic confrontation with the prevailing hegemonic order. Within each case, the analysis focuses on the political networks surrounding Reza Pahlavi in Iran and María Corina Machado in Venezuela. The theoretical framework combines Southern Theory with the Gramscian concept of hegemony. As Raewyn Connell argues, Southern Theory challenges the uncritical universalization of concepts produced within the Global North and subsequently presented as universally applicable analytical tools. From this perspective, the analytical validity of political science concepts depends on their sensitivity to social context and structures of power. Within critical International Relations scholarship, hegemony is understood as a relatively durable form of political order reproduced through the interaction of material capabilities, institutions, and the production of meaning. Drawing on Gramsci, Robert Cox argues that a hegemonic order becomes consolidated when the interests of dominant powers are articulated as universal norms and incorporated into what is perceived as political common sense. To operationalize the distinction between endogenous opposition and opposition aligned with dominant powers, the study examines three dimensions: external institutional and financial ties; support for economic sanctions; and the acceptance or normalization of external political pressure and military intervention. Findings and Discussion The political network surrounding Reza Pahlavi in Iran. The analysis identifies extensive financial and institutional connections between actors within this network and Western political and governmental institutions, particularly in the United States and Israel. The Iran Revival group is openly aligned with Pahlavi's political agenda, while its leaders have made substantial financial contributions to Republican politicians in the United States. Pahlavi has also maintained close relations with hawkish think tanks in Washington. His public visit to Israel in April 2023 and meeting with Benjamin Netanyahu further illustrate his alignment with a major regional power. He has described economic sanctions as a legitimate means of weakening the Islamic Republic and supported the Trump administration's withdrawal from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA). Following the U.S. assassination of General Qassem Soleimani, he characterized the action as a “positive development.” During the 2025 war, he likewise described Israeli attacks on Iran as a “historic opportunity” for regime change. The political network surrounding María Corina Machado in Venezuela. Machado's political ascent was accompanied from an early stage by material and institutional support from organizations aligned with U.S. foreign-policy interests. She was a co-founder of Súmate, which received financial support from the U.S. National Endowment for Democracy (NED), and was among those who signed the decree associated with the government formed during the 2002 coup attempt. Machado has also maintained close ties with the Atlas Network and was a guest of honor at the organization's Democracy Award ceremony in 2024. She has characterized international sanctions against Venezuela as a legitimate and necessary means of weakening the Maduro government. Since 2019, she has explicitly advocated activating a regional defense treaty as a basis for multinational military intervention against Maduro. In her communications with Netanyahu, she has also expressed support for Israeli policies during the Gaza war. Conclusion The comparative analysis of Iran and Venezuela suggests that certain opposition networks in the Global South may become aligned, through their political positions and external relationships, with mechanisms of pressure employed by dominant powers. Applying the three analytical indicators to the networks surrounding Reza Pahlavi and María Corina Machado reveals a significant degree of convergence, in the cases examined, between their political strategies and broader strategies of external pressure. This finding should not be interpreted as implying that these groups are directly controlled by foreign actors or that the same pattern applies to opposition movements throughout the Global South. Rather, it underscores the importance of examining opposition groups simultaneously in relation to their domestic social environment and the unequal structure of global power, while avoiding broad generalizations. Critically examining forms of opposition the Global South that become aligned with structures of domination does not entail denying the legitimacy of political dissent or justifying the conduct of incumbent governments. Rather, identifying the ways in which opposition groups may become aligned with global powers is essential to developing a more nuanced understanding of power, legitimacy, and political conflict in an unequal international order.

Sustainable Security in the Islamic Republic of Iran: An Analysis of Macro-Level Policy Documents

Sustainable Security in the Islamic Republic of Iran: An Analysis of Macro-Level Policy Documents

Volume 28, Issue 4, Spring 2026, Pages 11-48

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2026.540757.4302

Noorollah Gheisari, Mohammad Sadegh Aghaei

Abstract
Introduction
Although the concept of sustainable security was explicitly introduced for the first time in the General Policies of the Fifth Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, its underlying principles had long been reflected in the country's constitutional, legal, and policy frameworks. This study examines the conceptualization of sustainable security across Iran’s major policy documents, including the Constitution, the Iran Vision 1404 Document, the First through Fifth Development Plans, and the General Policies of the Fifth, Sixth, and Seventh Development Plans.
Drawing on the theoretical and empirical literature, the study identifies the components, indicators, and security reference objects associated with sustainable security and classifies them into four dimensions: political-social, economic, security-defense, and environmental. In this context, security reference objects encompass both human beings and other human-centered entities that become subjects of security concerns, as well as the conditions and environments in which they exist. The study seeks to answer the following question: How do the macro-level documents of the Islamic Republic of Iran conceptualize sustainable security and the measures required to sustain it?
Methodology
This research adopts an exploratory qualitative approach. The content, themes, security reference objects, components, and indicators of sustainable security embedded in accessible macro-level documents were examined through textual and content analysis. Following their identification, the extracted concepts and categories were systematically classified according to their structural and substantive similarities. The resulting framework organizes sustainable security into four principal dimensions: political-social, economic, security-defense, and environmental. The concepts of security and sustainability were further interpreted through thematic analysis.
Findings and Discussion
The findings indicate that although the term sustainable security appears explicitly only in the General Policies of the Fifth Development Plan, its core themes are evident throughout other major policy documents. The analysis reveals that the political-social dimension receives the greatest emphasis, followed by the economic and security-defense dimensions, while environmental considerations receive comparatively limited attention.
A similar pattern is observed regarding the situational aspects of sustainable security. Although the documents contain references to sustaining conditions and managing their interrelationships, this dimension remains insufficiently developed. Furthermore, the dominant perspective underlying security-sustaining measures appears to assume relatively stable conditions rather than dynamic, evolving, and potentially turbulent environments. Given the increasing complexity and uncertainty of contemporary security challenges, this assumption may limit the effectiveness of long-term security policies.
Conclusion
The sustainability of security has become an increasingly strategic concern in light of wars, social unrest, rapid technological transformations, and the emergence of new forms of political and social change. While Iran’s macro-level policy documents acknowledge the importance of sustainable security, their treatment of the concept lacks sufficient conceptual clarity and comprehensiveness. A more systematic understanding of sustainable security can help address existing shortcomings in policymaking and implementation. Moreover, the continuous adaptation of policies and programs to changing security conditions is essential for maintaining and enhancing sustainable security.

The Genomic Paradigm of National Security

The Genomic Paradigm of National Security

Volume 28, Issue 4, Spring 2026, Pages 49-77

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2026.569443.4355

Mohammad Masrour, Reza Nazari Emami

Abstract Introduction
The relationship between health and security has long attracted scholarly attention; however, the connection between health and national security was conceptualized more systematically in the post–Cold War era. Biological warfare and biothreats have consistently been regarded as major security concerns. Despite significant advances in biotechnology, particularly in genetics and genome-editing technologies, which have paved the way for a new generation of biological weapons, several factors—including the complexity of human biological responses, globalization, and the limited availability of population-scale genomic data—have constrained their widespread deployment. Recent developments in genomics, together with advances in artificial intelligence, big data analytics, and the emergence of Precision Public Health (PPH), have the potential to transform the collection and analysis of biological data. These developments may fundamentally reshape the role of genomic information in security affairs and give rise to a new national security paradigm in which genomic data constitute a central strategic asset.
This article examines the evolution of biotechnology and explores the role of the Precision Public Health genomic platform in transforming the concept of national security. It argues that these developments may establish the human body as an independent domain of warfare while simultaneously redefining social and human concepts. Focusing on Iran, the study further highlights the need for a new framework for genomic data security.
Methods
This study employs a qualitative research design based on a descriptive-analytical approach. Data were collected through documentary research, drawing on books, scholarly publications, policy reports, and official documents. The collected materials were analyzed qualitatively to identify key trends, patterns, and conceptual relationships relevant to the study.
Findings and Discussion
Although biological threats have been a persistent feature of human history and technologies such as CRISPR (short for “clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats”) genome editing have introduced unprecedented possibilities for biological manipulation, the lack of comprehensive population-level genomic information has limited the practical use of biological warfare, leaving it a relatively underexplored and poorly understood mode of conflict. Evidence suggests that these constraints are gradually diminishing, potentially paving the way for biological warfare to become a more conventional form of conflict. This prospect has been increasingly reflected in scientific literature, strategic reports, and statements by political leaders of major powers. The emergence of the Precision Public Health genomic platform is likely to accelerate this trend.
The Precision Public Health platform was developed to prevent disease through the integration of genomics, environmental and behavioral data, and advanced analytical technologies. Broadly speaking, the platform performs two primary functions: first, the collection of genomic information through expanding digital connectivity and the generation of large-scale data from all dimensions of human life; and second, the design of continuous, adaptive, and individualized interventions based on real-time data, for the purpose of shaping and engineering future trajectories. The realization of these objectives requires the comprehensive medicalization of both individuals and society. Consequently, the platform extends beyond healthcare and seeks to manage and optimize multiple aspects of human life through genomic data.
This transformation alters traditional patterns of data collection by shifting control away from governments and private institutions toward platform-based ecosystems capable of generating continuous real-time data. Within this emerging paradigm, competition among major powers for access to and influence over genomic data becomes increasingly significant. In Iran, genomic data collection remains largely dependent on traditional academic and private-sector institutions, with a primary emphasis on personalized medicine. Nevertheless, the rapid global expansion of Precision Public Health is likely to influence Iran in the near future.
Conclusion
By generating real-time, individual-level, and population-scale genomic data through the expansion of digital connectivity, the Precision Public Health platform has the potential to remove one of the principal barriers to biological warfare. Early indications of this transformation were evident during the COVID-19 pandemic, when advances in biotechnology enabled the rapid development of vaccines within approximately one year. Current initiatives aimed at reducing vaccine and therapeutic development timelines to as little as one hundred days further illustrate this trajectory. Such achievements depend on access to detailed genomic information concerning both human populations and pathogens, information that can be generated through the Precision Public Health platform. If fully realized, these developments may signal the beginning of a new era in biological warfare.
More broadly, Precision Public Health may establish a data-driven mode of governance that gives rise to a new genomic paradigm in which social, political, and security concepts are interpreted through a genomic lens. In such a paradigm, human beings may increasingly be understood as repositories of genomic data, leading to profound transformations in identity. Likewise, the state acquires new meaning as platform-based authority increasingly influences legitimacy, policymaking, and power. Ultimately, governmental institutions may become components of a broader system of governing intelligence, operating within a data-centric framework of authority.

A Conceptual Model of Cognitive Warfare in the Context of Modern Warfare: A Meta-Synthesis Approach

A Conceptual Model of Cognitive Warfare in the Context of Modern Warfare: A Meta-Synthesis Approach

Volume 28, Issue 3, Winter 2026, Pages 79-170

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.469702.4183

saeid madadi, norullah norani

Abstract Introduction
Historical analysis indicates that confrontation between opposing forces has been a persistent and enduring feature of human societies. Over time, warfare has evolved from rudimentary tactics into increasingly complex and multidimensional systems. First- through fourth-generation wars, each characterized by distinct features, have collectively shaped the evolution of warfare. Since the early 1990s, however, human beings and social systems have emerged as central elements of conflict, giving rise to a novel cognitive dimension within the traditional domains of war.
Cognitive warfare fundamentally constitutes a battlefield of minds, where the primary goal is to manipulate and transform individuals’ perceptual frameworks, beliefs, values, and decision-making processes. In this arena, humans function not only as targets but also as instruments of strategic influence. By leveraging modern media, social engineering, cyber operations, and advanced technologies, cognitive warfare enables actors to impose their will on adversaries without direct physical confrontation.
Despite the increasing significance of cognitive warfare in military, political, and societal contexts, the literature remains fragmented, often addressing narrow aspects of the phenomenon. To date, no comprehensive conceptual framework has been established to systematically define its key characteristics. Accordingly, the present study employs a meta-synthesis approach to integrate and interpret existing research, aiming to develop a comprehensive conceptual model that elucidates the core dimensions of cognitive warfare and provides a clear operational understanding within the sphere of modern warfare.
Methodology
To provide a holistic interpretation of cognitive warfare’s conceptual dimensions, this study adopts a meta-synthesis methodology based on the Mark W. Lipsey and David B. Wilson framework. The research process included the following stages:

Formulation of research questions
Systematic literature review
Identification and screening of relevant studies
Data extraction from selected studies
Qualitative analysis and synthesis of findings
Assessment of reliability and validity (quality control)
Presentation of results (utilizing Shannon entropy)

During the systematic review, scholarly articles published between 2017 and 2023 were retrieved from reputable national and international databases. Of 92 studies, 31 were ultimately selected as the primary data sources for the meta-synthesis.
Data from these studies were coded and categorized as either domestic or international. Extracted codes were then integrated using a comparative approach and organized into conceptual categories. In the analytical phase, Shannon entropy was employed to evaluate the relative importance of each code and the extent of support it received within the literature.
The study’s validity was ensured through both quantitative and qualitative measures. Quantitatively, the Kappa coefficient was calculated at 0.684, indicating substantial inter-coder agreement. Qualitatively, an independent expert conducted a secondary review. Additional criteria, including procedural transparency and the quality of the selected studies, were considered to strengthen the trustworthiness of the findings.
Findings and Discussion
The meta-synthesis yielded 12 core categories, 35 secondary codes, and 144 primary codes, forming the basis of the proposed conceptual model of cognitive warfare. The model addresses twelve defining dimensions: characteristics, objectives, tools, operational levels, methods and strategies, indicators of implementation, consequences, countermeasures, target audiences, domains of conflict, related concepts, and national approaches to cognitive warfare.
Shannon entropy analysis revealed that certain components—such as “management and transformation of societal perception,” “influence on the general public,” “use of social media,” and “societal polarization”—exhibit the highest significance in the literature. These were identified as key conceptual elements of cognitive warfare.
Integrating the findings of the 31 studies, the following definition of cognitive warfare is proposed:
Cognitive warfare is a coordinated set of covert, virtual, fluid, and software-mediated actions that leverage “information as content” and “modern media as tools” to intentionally control and modify human cognitive capacities (mind, emotions, and subconscious). Its objectives include erasing historical memory, altering behavioral patterns, and ultimately imposing will upon the political and social systems of the target society.
Conclusion
The evolution of warfare demonstrates a persistent inclination toward imposing will upon adversaries without direct confrontation, a trend that has shifted from physical domains to informational and cognitive arenas. Cognitive warfare, as the advanced manifestation of this trend, utilizes information, modern media, and sophisticated technologies to deliberately influence perception, decision-making, and behavior within target societies, undermining social capital and public trust.
The conceptual model developed in this study provides a clear and practical framework for understanding cognitive warfare and lays the groundwork for further research on related concepts, countermeasures, and threat assessment. The findings indicate that cognitive warfare has become a strategic priority for major powers, playing a pivotal role in shaping political, social, and cultural systems.
Theoretically, this study represents a significant contribution to the literature by systematically conceptualizing the multidimensional nature of cognitive warfare within a structured, multi-level model using a meta-synthesis approach. Effective understanding and counteraction of this phenomenon require moving beyond a solely security-focused perspective and recognizing cognitive warfare as inherently interdisciplinary, integrating insights from cognitive science, social psychology, communication studies, technology, and political science.
From a practical perspective, the findings highlight the need to foster cognitive literacy at societal and governance levels. Key strategies include developing resilient networks against information manipulation, strengthening social trust, enhancing critical thinking education, and establishing ethical frameworks for the application of cognitive technologies.
Ultimately, the proposed conceptual model provides a validated framework to guide future research and serves as a foundation for national policy formulation in cognitive security, complementing existing cyber and psychological security strategies.

Compounding Security Crises in Pakistan: Implications for the Islamic Republic of Iran

Compounding Security Crises in Pakistan: Implications for the Islamic Republic of Iran

Volume 28, Issue 3, Winter 2026, Pages 217-256

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.536150.4293

Somaye Morovati

Abstract  
Introduction
This study applies the theoretical framework of “compounding crises” to examine the interconnections among security, political, and economic threats in Pakistan and their direct implications for the national security of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Unlike traditional approaches that consider threats in isolation, this research demonstrates that the simultaneous occurrence of multiple crises in Pakistan does not constitute a series of isolated challenges. Rather, it represents a coordinated and mutually reinforcing process that has significantly eroded the central government’s capacity across operational, financial, and legitimacy dimensions. This situation has direct consequences for Iran’s eastern borders and its broader security environment.
Pakistan exemplifies a state confronted with concurrent and intensifying crises: from fundamentalist terrorism led by Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and ISIS-Khorasan, to separatist insurgencies in Balochistan and Sindh, and to geopolitical tensions with India and Afghanistan. The structural interlinkages among these crises have weakened Pakistan’s internal security and generated substantial spillover threats to Iran. Understanding the dynamics of compounding crises is therefore crucial for the formulation of Iran’s security policy.
Methodology
This study adopts a qualitative-interpretive approach. Data were collected from three primary sources:
1.      Documentary analysis, including authoritative security reports and data from regional research centers;
2.      Statistical data relating to security, terrorism, the economy, and public policy;
3.      Semi-structured interviews with Iranian diplomats and experts in regional security.
The study applies the compounding crises framework to examine how these crises interact and erode state capacity across operational, economic, and legitimacy dimensions. This framework provides a coherent and systematic understanding of the cross-cutting effects of crises, revealing the multi-layered weakening of Pakistan’s state structures.
Findings and Discussion
Three primary categories of crises in Pakistan were identified:
1.      Fundamentalist terrorism: The main actors are TTP and ISIS-Khorasan. Following developments in Afghanistan in 2021, these groups gained greater strategic depth and significantly intensified attacks in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. Data from Pakistan Institute for Peace Studies (PIPS) indicate that terrorist attacks increased by over 112% in 2024, with an additional 81% rise in the first quarter of 2025. This trend reflects a substantial escalation in violence and a growing erosion of Pakistan’s military operational capacity.
2.      Baloch and Sindhi separatist insurgencies: These groups have targeted critical infrastructure, including projects associated with the China–Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), energy networks, and foreign investors—particularly Chinese—thereby generating heightened security and economic threats. The “Majid Brigade”, as the suicide wing of the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA), has played a key role in operations against Pakistan’s strategic objectives.
3.      Border-related geopolitical crises: Tensions with India over Kashmir and ongoing instability along the Afghan border have led to asymmetric military deployments in Pakistan, reducing the army’s capacity to address internal threats and undermining effective crisis management.
The analysis further highlights:
·         Operational erosion: Pakistan’s military is engaged in a multi-front, attritional conflict, weakening strategic deterrence and limiting its ability to stabilize border regions.
·         Financial erosion: Security and counterterrorism expenditures exceed 4% of GDP. Alongside declining foreign investment and reliance on the IMF, Pakistan’s economy is trapped in a cycle of recession and insecurity.
·         Political legitimacy erosion: The government’s inability to manage multiple crises simultaneously has reduced public trust, intensified dissatisfaction, and weakened the military’s authority within the political system, severely constraining decision-making.
This issue also has the following implications for Iran:
1.      Security vacuum arising from Pakistan’s operational weaknesses has facilitated increased activity by terrorist groups such as Jaish al-Adl.
2.      Economic fragility has expanded informal economies across the Iran-Pakistan border, providing sustainable financial resources for terrorist organizations.
3.      Political instability and fragmented decision-making in Pakistan have reduced the effectiveness of bilateral security cooperation and increased the likelihood of border tensions.
Conclusion
Pakistan’s crises are cross-cutting, synergistic, and self-reinforcing, and the threats spilling over to Iran share these characteristics. Consequently, the security of Iran and Pakistan is mutually interdependent, and managing emerging threats requires a multidimensional and systematic approach. Three key strategies are proposed:
1.      Strengthen and institutionalize security and intelligence cooperation with Pakistan;
2.      Promote socio-economic development in Iran’s border regions to reduce the drivers of insecurity;
3.      Strategically manage geopolitical relations with China and India, given their influence on Pakistan’s crises.
In conclusion, only a comprehensive approach grounded in the understanding of compounding crises can effectively prevent the spread of insecurity along Iran’s eastern borders.

 

Analyzing Physical Factors Enhancing Women’s Sustainable Safety in Public Urban Spaces of Informal Settlements: The Case of the Harandi Neighborhood

Analyzing Physical Factors Enhancing Women’s Sustainable Safety in Public Urban Spaces of Informal Settlements: The Case of the Harandi Neighborhood

Volume 28, Issue 2, Autumn 2025

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.536588.4294

Ali Zeynali Azim, Mostafa Basiri, Farzad Zarbakhsh, Ayda Mostafazadeh Bazargan

Abstract Introduction
Degraded urban areas in Iran—particularly in Tehran—represent some of the most complex urban challenges. These neighborhoods are marked by physical decay, poor infrastructure, overcrowding, and fragmented spatial organization, which have led to declining living standards and rising social problems.
The Harandi neighborhood in Tehran’s District 12 exemplifies this condition. Despite its historical background and central location, Harandi has undergone significant physical and social decline over recent decades and is now considered one of the most insecure areas in the city. Narrow alleys, irregular street patterns, poor lighting, abandoned buildings, and neglected open spaces—combined with concentrated social issues—have made the neighborhood feel unsafe, especially for women who tend to be more sensitive to environmental cues.
Women living in or passing through Harandi often encounter spaces that lack visibility, environmental control, and a sense of comfort. This reduces their willingness to be present in public areas, reinforcing both spatial self-restriction and gender inequality. Despite repeated urban regeneration initiatives, the role of physical design in shaping women’s perceptions of safety has received little systematic attention.
This study takes Harandi as a case study to examine how physical and environmental features—such as lighting, pathway connectivity, visibility, land-use diversity, and maintenance—affect women’s sustainable sense of safety in public urban spaces.
 
Methodology
The study adopts a quantitative, field-based approach to explore how environmental qualities influence women’s perceived safety in one of Tehran’s degraded urban areas. Because the research focuses on women’s lived experiences and environmental perceptions, direct data collection from residents was essential.
A survey method using a structured questionnaire was employed. The study population included women residing in Harandi (District 12). According to official data, the neighborhood’s population is about 32,145, of which 12,647 are women. Women aged 18 and older formed the target group. Using the Cochran formula (95% confidence level, 5% margin of error), a sample of 367 participants was determined. Respondents were selected through stratified random sampling to ensure diversity in age and spatial distribution.
The questionnaire was developed based on theories in urban safety, environmental psychology, and urban design. It included items measuring lighting quality, street connectivity, visibility, land-use patterns, street furniture, maintenance, and perceived safety—rated on a five-point Likert scale from “strongly disagree” to “strongly agree.” After pilot testing and expert review, the instrument’s reliability was confirmed with a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.865, indicating high internal consistency.
Data analysis included descriptive statistics followed by structural equation modeling (SEM) using SmartPLS software. Model validity was tested through convergent and discriminant validity measures and path coefficients. The results provided a clear and evidence-based understanding of the current situation and helped identify design strategies to improve environmental quality and women’s sense of safety in degraded urban areas.
 
Findings and Discussion
The analysis shows that in degraded neighborhoods like Harandi, women’s sustainable safety results from the interaction of physical, functional, and perceptual factors. The most influential dimension was movement structure and accessibility (total effect = 0.49), demonstrating that organized, legible pathways strongly shape women’s feelings of safety.
Lighting quality ranked second (effect = 0.38). Sufficient, uniform lighting at night not only improves visibility but also signals social presence and informal surveillance, reducing the likelihood of “blind spots.”
Psychological safety ranked third (effect = 0.35), highlighting the importance of mental comfort, sense of control, and collective memory in shaping women’s perception of safety. Environmental maintenance (effect = 0.32) showed that cleanliness and well-kept surfaces are seen as indicators of active urban management and monitoring. Active land uses (effect = 0.29) enhance security by ensuring continuous presence and economic vitality. Street furniture (effect = 0.26) contributes indirectly to safety by increasing comfort and usability. Natural surveillance (effect = 0.24) and spatial legibility (effect = 0.20) also reduce anxiety through visibility and predictability.
The components ranked as follows:

Pathways and accessibility
Lighting
Psychological safety
Environmental maintenance
Active land uses
Street furniture
Natural surveillance
Spatial legibility

 
Conclusion
The study concludes that women’s sense of safety in degraded urban areas is a multifaceted phenomenon closely tied to environmental design quality. In Harandi, insecurity is not solely the result of social problems but also of physical decay, poor lighting, spatial fragmentation, and visual disorder.
The structural model shows that organized street networks and accessible routes play the most important role in creating sustainable safety. Predictable, connected, and visible spaces give women a stronger sense of control and comfort. Consistent and effective lighting—as a sign of supervision and social presence—was the second key factor. Psychological aspects, such as feelings of comfort and support, also contribute greatly to women’s willingness to be present and active in public spaces.
Conversely, poor maintenance, neglected spaces, and unsafe street furniture erode trust and increase anxiety. Overall, the findings emphasize that improving women’s safety in degraded urban fabrics cannot rely solely on policing or surveillance. A holistic approach that integrates physical, environmental, and perceptual dimensions is essential.
Sustainable safety is achieved when women can read and navigate their environment, feel visible, and recognize their presence as an integral part of the neighborhood’s social life.

Structural Analysis of Security Challenges in Southern Kerman Province: A Political–Military Perspective

Structural Analysis of Security Challenges in Southern Kerman Province: A Political–Military Perspective

Volume 28, Issue 2, Autumn 2025

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.539833.4300

Salman Dastafshan, ali morshedizad, Parviz Amini

Abstract  
 
Introduction
The southern parts of Kerman Province represent a strategically important and semi-border area that faces long-standing security challenges. Its proximity to Afghanistan and Pakistan, along with its considerable distance from the provincial capital, has contributed to persistent instability. The roots of insecurity in this region lie largely in internal issues—such as weak local governance, the center–periphery divide, the spread of illegal networks, and the dominance of the shadow economy—rather than in purely external threats.
Therefore, security in southern Kerman is multidimensional and deeply interconnected, where political, military, social, and economic factors overlap and cannot easily be separated.
 
Methodology
This study adopts a qualitative and structural approach within a systemic analytical framework. The MICMAC method (Cross-Impact Matrix Multiplication Applied to Classification) was used to identify key variables and map their interrelations.
The research sample included 50 local elites, such as governors, judges, journalists, and social–political activists. Participants were selected through purposeful sampling and theoretical saturation to ensure comprehensive and reliable data.
 
Findings and Discussion
1. Driving Variables

The penetration of local political groups into the informal and smuggling-based economy
The instrumental use of local forces within smuggling-related security structures
The normalization of violence due to the widespread use of illegal weapons
The interaction of military personnel with organized crime networks
The outmigration of elites and recruitment of youth into informal groups

2. Dependent Variables

High sensitivity to national security reforms and policies
The dual and sometimes conflicting roles of military and police forces
The significant influence of tribal leaders and ethnic elites in local governance

3. Independent Variables

Lack of strong local political parties and legal channels for participation
Public distrust toward security and judicial institutions
Limited political awareness among local elites

4. Regulatory Variables

Weak representation at the national political level
Elections used as tools to legitimize corrupt structures
Ethnic grievances and structural discrimination
Unequal distribution of political and security resources

 
Conclusion
Reforming the political–military security structure in southern Kerman requires comprehensive change across political, security, social and cultural dimensions. Sustainable stability depends on institutional coherence and transparency, active participation of citizens and local elites, rebuilding judicial and security institutions, and reducing the influence of informal networks and black-market economies.
MICMAC analysis reveals that the region’s security system is structurally unstable, characterized by complex, nonlinear relationships among variables. This instability is marked by:

Multidirectional and intersecting linkages—for example, between smuggling networks, political institutions, and security corruption—that defy linear policy solutions.
High centralization and interdependence—changes in one variable can trigger unpredictable chain reactions across the system.
Absence of stabilizing variables, making reform efforts difficult and requiring a holistic, system-wide approach.

According to MICMAC rankings, the three most influential drivers of instability are:

Penetration of local political actors into smuggling networks (Score: 490) – linking formal institutions with fuel and drug trafficking mafias, forming the nucleus of systemic corruption.
Instrumental use of local security forces by smuggling groups (Score: 459) – transforming local actors into enforcers of informal order, eroding social cohesion.
Normalization of violence and proliferation of illegal arms (Score: 440) – embedding violence into daily life and creating a culture of fear that undermines human security.

The most vulnerable dependent variables under these unstable conditions are:

Infiltration of official intelligence systems by corruption (Score: 477)
Dual and conflicting roles of security and military forces (Score: 440)
Mismatch between national security policy and border realities (Score: 428) – particularly due to the influx of undocumented migrants from the eastern borders.

Overall, these findings point to a systemic failure of formal institutions to fulfill their core functions, leaving southern Kerman exposed to threats from informal networks and illegal cross-border activities.

A Model of Non-Democratic Peace and the Security Structure in West Asia

A Model of Non-Democratic Peace and the Security Structure in West Asia

Volume 28, Issue 2, Autumn 2025

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.523702.4277

Siamak Bahrami

Abstract Introduction
Discussions of security have evolved along two main paths in the United States and Europe.
American scholars have generally adopted a problem-solving approach, developing theories within the frameworks of offensive and defensive realism, constructivism, and debates over the relative roles of power and institutions in maintaining order.

In contrast, Europeans—drawing on critical theory and emancipatory thought—have explored security through the lenses of critical security studies, feminism, the Copenhagen School, the Paris School, and post-structuralism.
In short, one tradition seeks to achieve security and prevent conflict within the existing international framework, while the other views that very framework as a source of insecurity and instability.
Since the 1980s, the growing influence of constructivist interpretations has helped bridge this divide. In this view, security is seen as distinct from both peace and power, and is understood as a relational concept that evolves through social interaction. Anarchy is conceived as a spectrum that must pass through its stages—from infancy to maturity and old age. Security, likewise, is understood as a relational discourse situated between the discourse of pure power and that of authentic social engagement.
Building on this theoretical foundation, this study examines the security structure of West Asia, which is marked by exclusivity, volatility, institutional fragility, and a tendency toward violence. It argues that the region remains trapped in a state of immature anarchy, where competition, mistrust and security dilemmas dominate and structural underdevelopment prevents the establishment of lasting peace.
This analysis is guided by two main questions:

What factors explain the persistence of this immature security structure?
How might it evolve toward a more mature and stable order?

The study adopts the view that security structures are not purely material or power-based but are also social constructs—shaped by shared knowledge, norms, and interactions. Accordingly, the regional order in West Asia results from both the distribution of power and patterns of social relations among its main actors.
 
Methodology
Questions such as “What is security?”, “How can it be achieved?”, and “At what level should it be constructed?” have produced a wide range of theoretical answers—from realism to critical theory. Similarly, debates over whether competition or cooperation dominates the international system—and over what constitutes the security referent object, security agent, and security model—have given rise to competing paradigms.
This study adopts a hybrid and integrative approach that seeks to bridge these divides. For this, it introduces a new conceptual framework—the Critical Non-Democratic Peace Model—based on the idea that the international system has shifted from a distributive to a multiplicative structure. In such a system, traditional theoretical frameworks are no longer sufficient to explain evolving dynamics. Therefore, we must either develop new theoretical perspectives or combine existing ones to capture this complexity.
To this end, the paper integrates insights from four major traditions:

Democratic Peace Theory
Holistic Constructivism
Critical Theory
Structural Realism

A mixed-method approach, combining qualitative and quantitative methods and relying on both library and online resources, is used to support the analysis.
 
Findings and Discussion
A central question in security studies has long been how peace emerges and under what conditions it can be sustained. In the context of West Asia, this question becomes even more pressing: Why has peace remained elusive in this region? Are the sources of instability internal, structural, or both? Does the absence of democratic governance explain the recurring conflicts—or is democracy itself irrelevant to regional security?
Drawing on the Critical Non-Democratic Peace Theory, this study argues that the key obstacle to stability in West Asia is the absence of a shared understanding of balance among the region’s main powers. Sustainable peace, therefore, does not depend primarily on a state’s political system—democratic or otherwise—but rather on whether regional actors can reach a mutual conception of equilibrium in their relations.
 
Conclusion
This research challenges the assumptions of Democratic Peace Theory, which holds that peace is achievable only among democratic states. The findings show that the four major powers in West Asia—Iran, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and Israel—each operate according to different logics of balance:

Iran: Balance of identity
Turkey: Balance of interests
Israel: Balance of threat
Saudi Arabia: Balance of power

Because these actors lack a common understanding of balance, their interactions are marked by persistent misperceptions, mistrust, and conflict.
The study further distinguishes between different types of peace:

A balance of power produces a fragile, fear-based peace.
A balance of interests leads to a more stable, institutionalized peace built on mutual benefits and interests.
A balance of threat or identity generates a normatively grounded peace—though the former is civic and democratic, while the latter tends to be ideological or sectarian.

Ultimately, the paper concludes that peace is not exclusive to democratic systems. Even non-democratic regions such as West Asia can achieve peace—provided that their leading states develop a shared sense of balance, regardless of the specific form that balance takes.
 

The Security Guidelines in the Tradition of Iranshahr Political Advice Literature: A Case Study of Saadi’s Bustan

The Security Guidelines in the Tradition of Iranshahr Political Advice Literature: A Case Study of Saadi’s Bustan

Volume 28, Issue 1, Summer 2025, Pages 7-33

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.517311.4268

Mostafa Khaleghpour, Reza Ayasseh

Abstract Introduction
This study explores the concept of security within the tradition of Iranian political advice literature, with a particular focus on Saadi’s Bustan. Persian literature played an important role in shaping a form of political thought where writers sought to caution rulers by appealing to ethical principles and the best interests of both rulers and the public. Among these, Saadi’s Bustan stands out as a text that offers a distinctive political perspective, representing a shift within the tradition of Iranian political advice literature. Saadi’s view is grounded in a unique understanding of human nature. He locates the legitimacy and grandeur of political power in the people, urging rulers to prioritize the public good and protect their subjects.
Due to Saadi’s distinctive anthropology and his different view of the basis of political legitimacy, his writings present a different conception of security—one that can be called “human security” or “people-centered security.”
Building on this new perspective on politics and legitimacy, and drawing on Saadi’s unique ideas about human nature, this paper seeks to identify the security guidelines embedded in Bustan.
 
Methodology
This study uses a qualitative approach with thematic analysis. We employ a three-stage coding process—open coding, axial coding, and selective coding—to carefully examine the text of Bustan and identify the security-related themes that are woven throughout.
 
Discussion and Results
Saadi’s understanding of security is deeply rooted in his political anthropology. While he recognizes that political power in Iran was traditionally pastoral, absolute, and despotic, he introduces a significant shift in Iranian political advice literature by grounding political legitimacy in the people rather than in the ruler alone.
For Saadi, a secure society is the natural outcome of just and fair governance. Security depends on rulers exercising power through a framework of values and concepts that prioritize justice. The ruler must understand that his power comes from the people and must use it to create a just and secure society. He must take into account the needs of different social classes, seek counsel from elders and youth alike, respect both warriors and scholars, rely on knowledge and wisdom, employ capable individuals, act wisely against enemies, punish those who threaten public safety, and support foreigners, merchants, and traders to foster a positive image of the country internationally.
From Saadi’s perspective, a secure society is the direct result of such responsible and just governance. Security is the ruler’s responsibility, and the people remain the primary security referent object.
 
Conclusion
In Bustan, security emerges as a complex, multi-dimensional concept fundamentally shaped by the ruler’s approach to governance. If rulers govern based on divine will, immutable natural laws, and the transient nature of human life—while upholding principles like justice, fairness, wisdom, tolerance, and public welfare—they can ensure social security and peace. Saadi insists that security and peace are unattainable without these elements.
Since Saadi lived in an era when monarchs held absolute and unchecked power, he used ideas like fatalism, immutable natural laws, and human mortality to remind rulers that political power is a tool meant to protect and serve the people—not a personal, divine right or an inherited privilege. Political power, in this view, belongs collectively to society and must be used for the common good.
This understanding of political power, where legitimacy depends on the consent of the governed, anticipates key ideas of modern political thought and remains highly relevant today. In a time when states dominate politics and security is mainly defined in national terms, the concept of human security—which can be traced back to classical texts like Bustan—offers a valuable alternative.
By shifting the focus of security to ordinary people—once seen as “subjects” but now acknowledged as citizens—and basing rulers’ legitimacy on their consent and support, this approach puts the safety and well-being of the people at the core of policymaking. This shift in political legitimacy—from divine right to popular approval—places the security and comfort of citizens at the very center of governance.

The Role of Representative Democracy in Strengthening Collective Subjectivity and Enhancing Social Resilience

The Role of Representative Democracy in Strengthening Collective Subjectivity and Enhancing Social Resilience

Volume 28, Issue 1, Summer 2025, Pages 93-113

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.491531.4217

Salman Sadeghizadeh

Abstract Introduction
Resilience refers to an individual's or community's ability to withstand pressures and recover after a crisis. It's a concept widely studied across various fields, including psychology, sociology, and politics. On a personal level, resilience involves coping with stress, adapting to change, and maintaining mental well-being. At the societal level, it means communities can respond effectively to economic, social, or political challenges.
Democracy, as a form of governance, is built on the principle of popular sovereignty. In democratic systems, citizens actively participate in political processes—such as voting and public debate—to influence government decisions. Core elements of democracy include human rights, freedom of expression, transparency, and the rule of law. Democracy allows individuals and groups to engage equally and freely in public affairs and play a meaningful role in shaping societal policies.
Through open and transparent mechanisms, democracy fosters dialogue among different segments of society. This inclusive process helps communities find collective, participatory solutions in times of crisis. For example, during an economic downturn, democratic societies can establish consultative bodies and incorporate public input into policymaking—ensuring broader representation and promoting economic resilience.
 
Methodology
The relationship between political order and social structure has long been a key concern in politics and sociology. In fact, this intersection has led to the emergence of “political sociology” as a distinct field. Within political sociology, three main approaches are common: a behavioral approach focused on individual actions; a group-based approach focused on social classes and group behavior; and a structural approach, which focuses on the role of state institutions.
By adopting the third approach—the structural and state-centered perspective within political sociology—we step into the realm of political theory, where the political order/system plays a decisive role in shaping social structures. Drawing on this framework, the study explores how democratic political systems can enhance social resilience by promoting what is referred to as “subject-based security”.
 
Discussion and Results
In democratic societies, social participation is a key principle. When people are actively involved in decision-making and governance, they develop a sense of responsibility and belonging that contributes to greater social resilience. In short, the more engaged people are in political and social life, the more resilient both individuals and communities become in the face of crises.
Democracy and resilience are mutually reinforcing. Democratic institutions can foster resilience, and in turn, a resilient society helps protect and sustain democratic systems. Democracies are often better equipped to turn crises into opportunities for social and political cohesion, using transparent and inclusive processes. Conversely, social resilience supports democracy by safeguarding it against both internal and external threats.
Therefore, a democratic political system, through its commitment to subject-based security can contribute significantly to social resilience. In contrast, non-democratic systems often rely on structure-based security, where power and control are concentrated at the top. In representative democracies, the "security pyramid" is built from the bottom up, grounded in society itself. In authoritarian regimes, the pyramid is structured from the top down, with security and control resting heavily in the hands of the ruling elite. In general, this study illustrates how democratic mechanisms support subject-based security, which in turn strengthens social resilience.
 
Conclusion
Representative democracy is both an institutional and a societal framework—it provides the foundation for various other dimensions of collective life. As outlined earlier, its security pyramid is rooted in the base of society, whereas non-democratic regimes rely on centralized, top-down power. Representative democracy fosters what can be called "securitization of subjectivity capacity" which contributes to system-wide resilience.
That said, democratic systems also face significant challenges when it comes to building and sustaining resilience. Three key issues include:

Crisis management inefficiencies – In some democracies, decision-making can be slow or overly complex, limiting effective responses to urgent crises.
Social and economic inequality – Even in democratic systems, inequality can lead to unrest and undermine social cohesion.
Rising political violence – In some cases, political competition can escalate into violence, threatening public security and weakening resilience.

 

Understanding the Relationship between Social and Security Issues from the Perspectives of Modern and Postmodern Paradigms: A Focus on the Ideas of Émile Durkheim and Jacques Derrida

Understanding the Relationship between Social and Security Issues from the Perspectives of Modern and Postmodern Paradigms: A Focus on the Ideas of Émile Durkheim and Jacques Derrida

Volume 28, Issue 1, Summer 2025, Pages 115-139

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.500724.4248

Nurullah nourani, Ali Alaei

Abstract Introduction
Understanding and addressing social and security issues today requires a deep and fundamental theoretical analysis based on dominant paradigms. This paper focuses on the ideas of Émile Durkheim and Jacques Derrida to compare how social and security issues are viewed from modern and postmodern paradigms. The main goal is to explore how social problems turn into security crises and to examine how these issues are understood, explained, and addressed within the frameworks of these two distinguished thinkers. This study also aims to offer a combined model that can be useful for current security policymaking.
Methodology
The study employs a qualitative method with a comparative and discourse analysis approach. Key concepts such as order, threat, cohesion, exclusion, and insecurity are explored through the works of Durkheim and Derrida. The analysis is structured around three steps—identifying, explaining, and addressing —to better understand the connection between social and security issues in both modern and postmodern paradigms. The main data comes from classic texts in sociology and political philosophy, analyzed conceptually.
Discussion and Results
According to Durkheim, social problems become security crises when social institutions fail to perform their roles and social cohesion weakens. Therefore, security depends on institutional order and social solidarity. His solutions focus on gradually reforming economic structures and strengthening intermediate institutions. On the other hand, Derrida sees security as a fluid, language-based, and discursive construct that is constantly reshaped through interaction with the Other and opposing categories like safe/risky. He warns that excessive securitization can lead to excluding others, structural violence, and creating more insecurity. Derrida’s method of deconstruction helps reveal contradictions within dominant discourses and exposes how exclusion and power operate in security processes. In short, Durkheim emphasizes objectivity and institution, while Derrida rethinks security in terms of meaning, difference, and accepting the Other.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that combining Durkheim’s and Derrida’s perspectives provides a comprehensive framework for analyzing security and shaping policies. Durkheim focuses on the function of social institutions and economic reform, while Derrida highlights the need to rethink closed security discourses and be open to differences and otherness. Together, their views offer policymakers a flexible, justice-oriented strategy for dealing with social and security challenges. Finally, the study stresses the importance of avoiding unnecessary securitization, accepting ontological insecurity, and building resilient social institutions to ensure sustainable security.

Factors Affecting Regional Security Governance in West Asia (2011-2020): A Comparative Study of Iran, Turkey, and Saudi Arabia

Factors Affecting Regional Security Governance in West Asia (2011-2020): A Comparative Study of Iran, Turkey, and Saudi Arabia

Volume 27, Issue 4, Spring 2025, Pages 115-141

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.497088.4239

Syed Jalal Dehghani Firoozabadi,, Hossein Salimi, Gholamali Chegenizadeh, Samira Akbari

Abstract Introduction
West Asia has long been a hotspot for various forms of violence. The complex and multifaceted security threats in the region—coupled with the inherent fragility of states—demand that security be redefined within a new, regional framework. To break away from traditional security policies, there is increasing emphasis on the growing role of non-state actors, established norms, and cooperative security arrangements. In this context, the concept of governance is offered as a means to describe both the dispersion of power and the emergence of new oversight mechanisms that counterbalance state dominance. As a result, regional security governance is now seen as an important form of collective security. With this in mind, this study focuses on three key regional powers—Iran, Turkey, and Saudi Arabia—to examine the process of security governance and the factors that shape it.
Methodology
The study employs a mixed-methods approach. On the quantitative side, international data were analyzed to review the progress of regional security governance over the past decade. For the qualitative aspect, a focus group session was conducted with 10 experts (9 men and 1 woman), and the discussions were analyzed using MAXQDA software.
Discussion and Results
In terms of persuasive (or soft) policies, Iran’s performance improved steadily, with its score rising from 20 in 2012 to over 24 in 2016. Conversely, Saudi Arabia’s persuasive policy score dropped from 48 in 2011 to about 33 in 2022, and Turkey also followed a downward trend. Regarding coercive (or hard) policies, Saudi Arabia achieved the highest score of 70 in 2015, while Iran recorded the lowest score of 40 in 2013. Additionally, Iran has been more effective in countering ISIS, whereas Saudi Arabia and Turkey escalated tensions with their military operations in Yemen and parts of Iraq and Syria, respectively. While Iran demonstrated that regional security is a top priority in its fight against ISIS, Turkey generally focused on protecting its borders from refugees and terrorist attacks, even seizing opportunities to intervene in Syria. The qualitative analysis identified 9 main categories and 25 sub-categories (with a total frequency of 310 mentions). Data analysis revealed that 84% of the obstacles to regional security governance in West Asia were associated with persuasive (soft) policies, while only 16% were linked to coercive (hard) measures. This finding suggests that before resorting to hard security tools, establishing regional security governance in this region should primarily rely on diplomatic dialogue and softer forms of engagement.
Conclusion
Focusing on Iran, Turkey, and Saudi Arabia, this research identifies both positive and negative factors influencing regional security governance in West Asia from 2011 to 2022. The study shows that security in the region cannot be ensured by governments alone. Instead, the active participation of non-state actors, international organizations, and a mix of persuasive (diplomatic and economic) and coercive (military and security) tools are crucial to shaping regional security governance. The analysis also indicates significant differences among the regional powers.Their national objectives tend to be almost diametrically opposed, resulting in a fluctuating form of regional security governance. For instance, the persuasive tools used by Iran in resolving regional disputes averaged a score of 22, compared to averages of 36 and 38 for Saudi Arabia and Turkey, respectively. While Saudi Arabia and Turkey show similar tendencies in their use of persuasive and coercive methods, Iran has taken a notably different approach. Reflecting on Europe's approach to regional security governance, it’s clear that after World War II, European nations were able to adopt a democracy-based framework with support from the United States that led to nearly uniform responses to conflicts.
However, in West Asia, the role of major powers has had the opposite effect—fueling tensions and exacerbating conflicts. Their involvement, most notably their support for the establishment of Israel, has contributed to major issues such as the Arab-Israeli wars, increased securitization, and a drift toward authoritarianism among regional governments. The military presence of extra-regional powers has pressured these countries to prioritize military solutions instead of diplomatic ones. Furthermore, the region’s geopolitical and economic significance continues to fuel competition among thses powers. Rivalries, such as that between China and the United States, have even led to bloc formations in the region, potentially undermining the development of regional security governance. Even the region's failed state- and nation-building process—which is seen as one of the main reasons why this form of governance has not been established in West Asia—has been influenced, to some extent, by the Sykes-Picot Agreement and by Israel.
The qualitative findings further highlight that regional powers’ abilities to protect their societies (by leveraging resources for defense and military intervention), combined with their unique interpretations of security and stability, domestic multi-actor dynamics (involving the role of non-state actors), and external delegations to regional organizations, are among the key factors shaping regional security governance. On the other hand, issues such as the Israel factor, extra-regional interventions, authoritarian tendencies, strategic culture, border disputes, and incomplete or unsynchronized political and economic structures have negatively affected its development.

Understanding the Biden Administration’s Hybrid Containment Strategy Towards Iran

Understanding the Biden Administration’s "Hybrid Containment" Strategy Towards Iran

Volume 27, Issue 4, Spring 2025, Pages 143-176

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2024.493080.4220

Mohamad Hadi Raji, , abuzar Gohari Moqadam, Majid Shakeri, Mostafa Koshki

Abstract Introduction
The relationship between Iran and the United States has been turbulent, especially following the 1979 Islamic Revolution. Both Democratic and Republican administrations have used different strategies to pressure Iran, making this one of the most complex relationships in international affairs. Examining this dynamic—particularly in light of major historical events like the 1953 coup and the post-1979 tensions—is a multi-layered challenge that goes beyond politics. It also involves sociology, economics, and security studies, reflecting the deep and evolving complexities of global power structures. However, over the years, scholars and analysts have studied the various strategies the U.S. has employed against Iran, identifying patterns of hostility. This paper focuses on the Biden administration’s approach, assessing how it builds on past U.S. policies while introducing its own methods in response to global changes.
Methodology
This study explores a key question: What framework defines the "Hybrid Containment" strategy used by the Biden administration against Iran? The main goal is to understand how the U.S. applies a mix of tactics to exert pressure on Iran. The research is both theoretical and practical, contributing to policy discussions while offering operational insights. It relies on documentary and library sources, combining deductive and inductive reasoning, and uses a descriptive-analytical approach for interpretation. Since the study is exploratory, it does not test specific hypotheses.
Discussion and Results
The study finds that the Biden administration’s approach to Iran falls under the concept of "Hybrid Containment in a Complex Environment." This strategy reflects the unpredictable and deeply interconnected nature of economic, security, and social factors influencing global relations today. Because of this complexity, two key aspects—planning and exploitation —are essential. The U.S. aims not only to structure a containment strategy for Iran but also to take advantage of unexpected developments and interactions.
Washington’s approach involves two main elements: deterrence (blocking Iran’s actions) and compellence (forcing Iran to comply). This strategy is shaped by broader shifts in global power dynamics, particularly the U.S. effort to manage its declining influence while countering emerging powers like China. Moreover, the foundation of U.S. policy toward Iran operates on two levels. The first level concerns Iran itself—its post-revolution identity and the nature of the Islamic Republic. The second level involves Iran’s geopolitical and economic significance, particularly its role in China’s Belt and Road Initiative and Russia’s access to southern trade routes. The Ukraine war has, in turn, increased Iran’s strategic importance in global trade.
To counter Iran’s influence, the U.S. has adopted two key strategies:

"Neither Negotiation nor Confrontation" – Keeping Iran in a frozen state diplomatically while minimizing its geopolitical relevance.
Undermining the legitimacy of the Islamic Republic – Portraying Iran as ineffective and creating social divisions.

Within these strategies, the U.S. and its allies employ various techniques. One common approach is gray-zone deterrence, applying pressure below the threshold of open war to limit Iran’s ability to respond. Specific tactics include:

Expanding economic sanctions, disrupting Iran’s oil exports, and interfering with financial transactions.
Supporting a network of terrorist groups and regional allies—including India, Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Israel—as a counterweight to Iran’s axis of resistance and China’s Belt and Road Initiative.
Using media and psychological tactics to weaken Iran’s domestic unity, polarizing society, and questioning the future of the resistance movement.

Conclusion
The Biden administration’s Iran strategy reflects a blend of historical precedents and modern geopolitical shifts. Its hybrid containment model operates within a deeply interconnected global environment, balancing deterrence with strategic exploitation. The U.S. aims to limit Iran’s regional influence while shaping a global order that preserves American power in an era of rising competition.

Pathology of Transgenic Products Policies in the Islamic Republic of Iran

Pathology of Transgenic Products Policies in the Islamic Republic of Iran

Volume 27, Issue 2, Summer 2024, Pages 41-64

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2024.433574.4128

Masoud Jabalameli, Mohammad Reza Yazdani Zazerani, Mahnaz Goodarzi

Abstract In the era of globalization, there has been a tremendous transformation in both the sources of threats and the types of threats and the tools used. Threats in the era of globalization are not state-oriented and the focus on military threats has become less. Since the beginning of the Islamic Revolution, Iran has been involved in the harsh aspects of threats such as imposed war and terror but with the emergence of new aspects of these threats such as genetically modified crops, the country's security has undergone many threats and transformations. This research tried to answer the question that what are the harms of policies related to new biological threats against Iran? Therefore, this research was looking for the pathology of G.A.'s policies against new biological threats, focusing on transgenic products. Based on the research findings; Policies in this area have been made in the form of codified laws or under the country's development plans, but the lack of comprehensive policies or the weakness of the current policies, as well as their lack of diagnosis, have caused disagreements or gaps in this field, so the current laws need to be updated. In addition to that, in some areas, the existing deficiencies must be compensated with new legislations. The results of the research have divided the existing harms in the country's policy into four categories of functional, structural, contextual and communication factors. In this research, the qualitative content analysis method was used to analyze the data.

Trust and Terrorism: A Sociological Study of West Asia (2007-2020)

Trust and Terrorism: A Sociological Study of West Asia (2007-2020)

Volume 27, Issue 2, Summer 2024, Pages 115-146

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2024.434713.4125

Abolfazl Delavari, Reza Khalili, Hamed Mehraban inchebroun

Abstract  
Introduction
The rise of West Asia as a hub for various terrorist groups, many of which are linked to Islam and operate on a global scale, has led to a growing connection between global terrorism and Islam. According to data from the “National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START),” between 2012 and 2017, 17 terrorist groups conducted attacks in Europe, compared to 148 in the West Asia and North Africa. A key concern, beyond the number of active terrorist groups, is the severity of their violence. For instance, during this period, ISIS alone was responsible for 5,646 terrorist attacks, resulting in 39,744 deaths and 856 injuries. In 2012, Europe saw 13 attacks, while Iraq recorded 319. By 2017, Europe experienced 40 attacks (14 in Russia), whereas Iraq faced 1,160 attacks.
In explaining the factors behind the rise of terrorist groups and the intensity of their violence, particularly in West Asia, experts and analysts have pointed to various causes such as political instability, economic conditions, cultural characteristics, and psychological disorders. While each of these factors can shed light on aspects of the issue, it is essential to recognize that “terrorism is primarily linked to social factors.” Unlike criminal activities driven by selfish motives, terrorists often believe their actions serve a collective, altruistic goal, highlighting a deeply social dimension. Therefore, social factors, especially community-level trust, play a crucial role in understanding the formation of terrorism and the behavior of terrorists.
 
Methodology
The paper adopts a quantitative approach, is periodical in nature, and relies on secondary data sources such as The Legatum Prosperity Index, the Global Terrorism Database, and START. Trust and terrorism are examined as the independent and dependent variables, respectively. Data analysis was conducted using SPSS version 22. The study focuses on West Asian countries, with sampling performed using the hierarchical clustering method known as “Ward.”
 
Discussion and Results
Qatar ranks highest in institutional trust, with an impressive average score of 98, while Yemen lags far behind with a score of just 11, indicating the weakest institutional trust. In terms of generalized interpersonal trust, Yemen surprisingly leads with a score of 81, whereas Iraq records the lowest score at 31. On the international trust front, Qatar again performs well with an average score of 60, contrasting sharply with Iraq, which has the lowest score of 20.
Throughout the studied period, Iraq experienced a total of 6,205 terrorist attacks, averaging 443 attacks per year. Syria had the highest number of terrorist groups, with a total of 74 operating in the country, resulting in an average of over five groups conducting terrorist operations annually. Iraq also recorded the highest intensity of violence, with approximately 53,000 casualties, meaning that around 4,000 people were killed or wounded in the country each year.
Out of the nine possible correlations between the three levels of trust and various components of terrorism, five showed significant relationships. Specifically, there was a significant correlation between interpersonal trust and the number of attacks; institutional trust was significantly related to both the intensity of violence and the number of attacks; and international trust had a significant connection with both the number of terrorist groups and their attacks.
 
Conclusion
In general, this research aligns with the findings of other scholars in showing that in societies with high levels of interpersonal trust, the formation of terrorist groups is more likely, while an increase in institutional trust correlates with a decrease in violence. However, a unique finding of this study is that a rise in international trust has led to an increase in both the number of terrorist groups and their attacks in West Asia. This divergence from other research may be attributed to the deep roots of Islamic culture in the region and the anti-social tendencies of authoritarian rulers in West Asian countries, who, while engaging with globalization, lean toward liberalism. Therefore, it can be concluded that the lack of mature institutional structures in the region prompts citizens to respond by forming or joining terrorist groups, escalating both the number of attacks and the intensity of violence.

Building a Theory of Politicization of Intelligence

Building a Theory of Politicization of Intelligence

Volume 27, Issue 1, Spring 2024, Pages 71-86

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2024.390870.4040

Gholamreza Salarkia

Abstract Introduction
Historically, intelligence has consistently been under political scrutiny, with intelligence elites often perceived as political servants. Intelligence, leveraging its ability to operate covertly, strives to supply the necessary data for policymakers to make informed decisions. Essentially, the primary objective of intelligence is to aid users in decision-making processes regarding potential actions. Against this background, it becomes crucial that intelligence remains unbiased and is not swayed by the political inclinations of a country’s political factions and parties, internal and external organizational interests, or the personal interests of politicians.
Intelligence operations should be conducted independently of political goals, and only the results derived should be presented to politicians. Fundamentally, intelligence agencies should prioritize national interests and remain detached from political, group, and personal interests. Thus, supporting policy-making differs from favoring a policy to the extent that objectivity is overlooked. The quintessence of the ideal relationship between intelligence and politics should be articulated as follows: Intelligence should serve the realm of politics, not its political overlords.
However, when the political environment influences intelligence to the point where intelligence outputs demonstrate a political leaning, we observe the phenomenon of intelligence politicization. Literature on intelligence indicates that politicization occurs when intelligence analysts, whether consciously or unconsciously, are swayed to generate outcomes that align with policymakers’ desires, rather than delivering the truth. This scenario represents a significant departure from the fundamental responsibility of intelligence, which is to tell the truth to those in authority.
 
Methodology
The politicization theory is formulated within the context of case studies. Essentially, it’s a research approach that involves the use of one or more case examples to construct theoretical frameworks, propositions, or mid-level theories, all of which are grounded in case-specific and empirical evidence. The key idea is that the employment of case examples forms the foundation for theory in an inductive way. In this approach, the theory evolves by identifying patterns of relationships both between and within the structures of case examples and their inherent logical arguments. This type of theory is rooted in the theorizing methodology of Paul R. Carlile and Clayton M. Christensen, following the pyramid of theorizing. Here, the politicization within intelligence agencies (both domestic and international) is examined through methods such as observation, interviews, and the study of secondary documents (library research). Following the theoretical framework of Carlile and Christensen, multiple cases were initially investigated. Subsequently, the observed elements were categorized. The relationships among the identified elements were then discerned. Ultimately, the primary propositions were established.
 
Result and Discussion
The theory of intelligence politicization encompasses two primary dimensions as detailed below:

Behavioral Dimension of Politicization

This refers to the elements that form the foundation of politicization within an intelligence organization. In the absence of these elements, politicization would not manifest. However, since some of them are inherent to the nature and essence of the intelligence organization, they internalize and institutionalize politicization. This dimension of politicization is deemed a necessary, but not sufficient precondition for the emergence of politicization in intelligence organizations. The behavioral dimension is subdivided into three categories: intelligence officer behavior, organizational behavior, and environmental behavior.
The behavior of the intelligence officer is influenced by a collection of factors that shape their individual actions. Organizational behavior is determined by factors that originate from the organization and its structure. Environmental behavior encompasses all factors that exist outside the intelligence organization, essentially residing in its external environment.

The Process Dimension of Politicization

This dimension refers to the actions and processes that give rise to politicization. By actualizing politicization, they induce alterations in the structure of politicization. This represents one of the sufficient, but not necessary, preconditions for the occurrence of politicization within intelligence organizations.
The process dimension of politicization is divided into three categories: “high process factors”, “low process factors”, and “online process factors”. The first encompasses all elements that are influenced by the policymaker to instigate politicization within the intelligence organization. The second refers to those elements that are executed by intelligence officers (except senior intelligence directors) to induce politicization. Given that in governmental bureaucracies, the appointment of directors is a critical phase in policy making and its execution, the emergence of politicization by intelligence directors is categorized separately under the third label of “online process factors”.

Political Parties and Their Impact on Security Governance in the Islamic Republic of Iran

Political Parties and Their Impact on Security Governance in the Islamic Republic of Iran

Volume 26, Issue 4, Winter 2024, Pages 29-50

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2024.421651.4112

heidar shahriari

Abstract Introduction
In recent decades, the concept of a security governance model—where public and private sectors collaborate with the government to provide security—has drawn significant interest. Its potential impact on reducing security costs has prompted scholars in the field of politics and security across various countries to explore its characteristics, implementation methods, influencing factors, and underlying foundations.
While limited theoretical and practical work has been conducted on this issue, it appears that political parties play a crucial role in security governance within different societies, including Iran. Recognizing their significance in providing security, both the broader political society and security practitioners should prioritize their establishments in programs and policies to ensure comprehensive security.
This paper aims to examine the influence of political parties on security governance. It assumes that political parties significantly impact security governance through functions such as promoting accountability, fostering culturalization, and facilitating coordination among security agencies (which form the foundations of security governance). Additionally, political parties contribute to increased participation from public and private sectors, resource accumulation for providing security, and the advancement of decentralized policy-making and decision-making (which serve as indicators of effective security governance).
Methodology
This study adopts the theory of structure-agent or structuration. According to this approach, both structuralism and voluntarism represent single-causal and simplistic views that fail to fully analyze complex events in human society. Consequently, a synthesis of these perspectives is necessary. While structuralism emphasizes the supremacy of structures, attributing socio-political events to their influence, voluntarism takes the opposite stance. In the voluntarism perspective, the role of the human agent is central, and structures are seen as products of voluntary action.
However, the structuration theory adeptly combines these two perspectives in a nuanced and innovative manner, effectively addressing criticisms of the methodology. According to Anthony Giddens, one of the early proponents of this theory, the interaction between agents and structures situates actors within their action environment. Consequently, the outcomes of individual actions are shaped by both the specific actions themselves and the broader contextual framework. These structures play a dual role: they mediate agents’ actions, that is, shaping the conditions within which those actions occur, while also undergoing reconstruction through those very actions.
This paper seeks to examine the role of political parties in security provision within the security governance model, drawing on structuration theory. By adopting this approach, we gain insights into the geographical, cultural, and political structures that either constrain or enhance the influence of political parties in Iran. Additionally, it enables statesmen to grasp the limitations and capabilities of political parties, emphasizing their pivotal role as a decisive factor in achieving effective and comprehensive security within the security governance framework.
Result and Discussion
The initial step toward developing security governance in Iran involves the establishment of robust political parties. Subsequently, socio-cultural structures must be crafted, alongside the realization of security governance indicators. These structures encompass important metrics such as culturalization, public acceptance, coordination, and responsibility. Their significance is such that constructing an effective security governance model hinges upon them.
Governance indicators involve various metrics, including private and public sector participation, decentralized policy implementation and decision-making, resource mobilization for security, geographical decentralization, and the cultivation of a comprehensive security perspective. Consequently, statesmen play a crucial role in recognizing the significance of political parties. Simultaneously, their attention to historical and existing structures is vital for realizing an effective security governance model that aligns with Iran’s present and future context.
The current model of security governance in Iran is both desirable and necessary. It is desirable because citizens have the right to participate in political and security affairs. Moreover, it is necessary due to the complexities of providing security in today's decentralized, complex, and interconnected world. Achieving cost reduction and optimizing security mechanisms require active participation from both the public and private sectors within the security governance framework. Iran, like any other country, is intricately connected to the global network of governance. Therefore, understanding the efficiency and necessity of such a model is crucial. An important question for future research is to what extent the existing political system is prepared to adapt and embrace the requirements and dimensions of the security governance model.
 

Contextual Factors and Causes of Prolonged Ethnic Conflicts: A Case Study of the PKK in Turkey

Contextual Factors and Causes of Prolonged Ethnic Conflicts: A Case Study of the PKK in Turkey

Volume 26, Issue 4, Winter 2024, Pages 85-102

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2024.428967.4118

Muhammad Ali Qasemi Tarki

Abstract  
Introduction
Protracted or intractable ethnic conflicts are a type of clashes that, despite fluctuating levels of violence, seem to have no foreseeable resolution. An example of such a conflict is the PKK (Kurdistan Workers' Party) crisis in Turkey. Despite its four-decade history and significant political and social impacts on the country, there appears to be no clear end in sight. The persistence of these conflicts not only jeopardizes the security of the conflict-ridden nation but also has a ripple effect on neighboring countries, draining their resources and hindering their development and prosperity. This paper aims to comprehend these enduring ethnic conflicts and analyze the factors and causes influencing them, using the PKK as a case study.
Methodology
When it comes to the causes of ethnic conflicts, there are numerous theories and models, but their universality and comprehensiveness are often questioned. For instance, Ted Robert Gurr proposed four categories: salience for ethnocultural identity, incentives for action, dynamics for protracted conflicts, and capacity for action, each with its own facets and dimensions. Another scholar, Stuart J. Kaufman, believes that the outbidding of ethnic elites and their manipulation of ethnic symbols play a significant role in inciting hostility against the government or other ethnic groups. Shiping Tang, on the other hand, considers the four master drivers: emotion, interest, capability, and opportunity. As for the prolongation of conflicts, James Samuel Coleman identifies four dimensions: the context of the conflict, the issues at stake, the relations among ethnic groups, and the processes, outcomes, and consequences of the conflict.
This paper proposes a model based on the philosophical principle that “the persistence of an effect is contingent on the persistence of its cause”. According to this model, the perpetuation of dissatisfaction or the emergence of new dissatisfaction (either through the ongoing framing of contentious issues or their reframing) results in the perpetuation of the cycle of violence and revenge. This situation is further exacerbated by the enduring presence of international supporters or the emergence of new backers. Concurrently, these conditions solidify the geopolitical factors that have played a role in initiating and perpetuating ethnic conflicts.
Result and Discussion
The PKK emerged during the radical period of the 1970s in Turkey. This group highlighted the need to secure the national and ethnic rights of the Kurds, in addition to addressing the underdevelopment of Kurdish regions. The initiation of armed conflict by this group provoked a strong governmental response, leading to forced displacement, the declaration of a state of emergency, and an escalation in violence. Consequently, a broader segment of Kurdish society was drawn into the conflict.
Despite the fulfillment of some Kurdish demands during Erdogan’s tenure, particularly in the early years, the PKK and affiliated groups introduced new demands and a fresh framework of issues and conflicts. This group maintains its financial resources by engaging in smuggling and a variety of illicit activities. It has gained international supporters, in part due to the rise of ISIS and the need for extra-regional powers to leverage the PKK forces in combating it. By establishing a monopoly over Kurdish representation and eliminating potential competitors, the group has managed to maintain its position in the political landscape of Kurdish society and Turkey. Meanwhile, the geopolitics of the Kurdish regions remain relatively unchanged. On the other hand, the limited control exerted by Turkey’s neighbors over the country’s southern borders has not impeded border crossings, thereby reducing the effectiveness of the Turkish forces’ military pursuit of the PKK group.

The Islamic Republic of Iran and the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works: A Cultural Security Perspective

The Islamic Republic of Iran and the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works: A Cultural Security Perspective

Volume 26, Issue 3, Autumn 2023, Pages 67-89

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2023.399677.4062

mojtaba jafarzadeh, Hesamodin Ashna

Abstract Extended Abstract

Introduction:
Cultural security encompasses a broad and diverse range of aspects. To safeguard this, states implement comprehensive strategies such as communication restrictions, national culture promotion, and the development of educational programs. Additionally, the membership of the international treaties and conventions is another measure to reinforce the regulation of cultural consumption, thereby enhancing cultural security.
Numerous international treaties and conventions exist to safeguard and bolster the cultural heritage of nations. Among these, the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works stands out as a significant one, with widespread global participation. This convention primarily aims to establish fundamental principles for copyright protection and to uphold the rights of copyright holders. In essence, it seeks to advocate for creators in the realms of science and culture. However, the convention also plays a crucial role in regulating and overseeing the consumption of cultural and artistic products. This, in turn, can have significant implications, either strengthening or undermining a country’s cultural security.
This study tries to explain the consequences of accepting the Berne Convention on the cultural security of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Also, a proper strategy is suggested so that it fits the daily needs of Iranian society and has a positive effect on its cultural security.
Methodology:
Initially, available resources concerning the repercussions of Iran’s accession to the Berne Convention were identified, and 330 arguments from both proponents and critics were extracted. These items were subsequently categorized into 15 overarching themes using a ‘Thematic Analysis’ approach. These themes served as the foundation for a ‘descriptive and analytical review’ of the Berne Convention’s impact on Iran’s cultural security. In this context, the viewpoints of proponents and critics were analyzed across seven dimensions: cultural access, per capita cultural consumption, resistance to cultural imperialism, protection of national interests, cultural independence and self-sufficiency, innovation and creativity, and jurisprudential issues.
Discussion and Results:
For the authors of this study, the paramount consideration is the compelling argument put forth by proponents of the Berne Convention, as compared to its critics. They assert that by joining this convention, the Islamic Republic of Iran can acquire significant tools to fortify national identity and ward off cultural encroachment. This is primarily because the convention encompasses regulations and frameworks that can assist the state in cultivating and propagating Iranian-Islamic culture, while simultaneously curbing the illicit trafficking and consumption of Western media products.
Conversely, if the Berne Convention is not accepted, foreign cultural products could become widely accessible at low cost or even free of charge. This could lead to a surge in the smuggling and consumption of such products, which are often laden with colonial ideological indoctrination. With the rapid advancement of communication technologies, this issue could escalate, leading to more severe consequences. It could engender a sense of despair within society, hinder social cohesion and unity, and give rise to various cultural and social crises.
Advocates also argue that joining this convention is a means of safeguarding the nation’s public and national interests. It lays the groundwork for global cooperation through cultural and scientific exchange, fostering the country’s cultural, artistic, and scientific growth. By enhancing these conditions domestically, it opens avenues for international engagement and draws greater attention to Iranian-Islamic culture. Overall, it paves the way for the development of a cultural and artistic economic market, thereby strengthening and shaping the country’s cultural system.
Conclusion:
This study concludes that the Berne Convention can serve as an international legal framework for achieving the country’s social and cultural objectives, as well as enhancing its cultural security conditions. Therefore, to further bolster cultural security and foster the growth of the nation’s cultural system, it is recommended that policymakers facilitate the necessary coordination among cultural, artistic, and scientific institutions for the country’s accession to this convention.

 

National security as a Political Quistion Doctrine in the Practice of the Supreme Court of the United States of America

National security as a Political Quistion Doctrine in the Practice of the Supreme Court of the United States of America

Volume 26, Issue 3, Autumn 2023, Pages 137-153

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2023.411728.4091

mehdi rezaei

Abstract Extended Abstract

Introduction:
Judicialization of politics and the doctrine of political quistion are among the components of constitutionalization in the constitutional legal system of the United States of America. Therefore, the supremacy of the constitution considered as the main pillar of the American political order.
Judicialization of politics in the United States is important, beacause modifying the doctrine of political quistion and through basic proceedings, issues have been brought into the jurisdiction and decision making of the courts, especially the Supreme Court, which have traditionally been classified as "political quistion" outside the judicial reviw United States.
 
Lawsuits related to national security in the Supreme Court of the United States were considered as political questions and decision-making was left to the executive and legislative powers.In two cases presented, by separating the internal and external dimensions of national security, the Supreme Court considered the internal dimensions of national security outside of the political question and decided on it.
Referring to the second article of the Constitution, the Supreme Court of the United States argues that the President is the only representative of the country in international affairs. The court also introduces the president as not only the head of the executive branch but also the commander-in-chief of the armed forces. Therefore, he has the authority to make decisions about the interests and external aspects of national security. Of course, he is responsible for these powers and must be accountable. In order to guarantee the principles of republicanism and democracy, the constitution deems judicial supervision of the president's decisions regarding national security inevitable.
No article or book has been published in Persian about judicialization and national security. The author of this article has previously published an article about the governance of national security and judicialization in Iran's judicial system. Research on the issue of politics and radicalization in the United States is available. However, considering national security as a political issue and explaining the procedure of the court in examining related claims can be considered the main issue and innovation of this article.
 
Methodology:
The results of this research are based on the theoretical foundations of the concepts of judicialization and political quistion. After analyzing the theoretical foundations, two decisions of the Supreme Court of America have been analyzed and analyzed based on the commentator-oriented interpretation method. First, the opinion of the judges of the court is stated, and then the criteria for decision-making and the governing principles of the method of interpreting the text of the constitution are explained.
Conclusion:
The research results indicate the following. (a) Ambiguity in the concept of national security in the legal system of the United States of America. (b) The extensive authority of the president as the commander-in-chief and also the sole representative of the nation in international relations has created a constitutional crisis. (c) The separation of national security interests in the internal and external dimensions has determined the political quistion. (d) The external dimension of national security is considered a political question and the court refuses to hear legal claims in this regard. The Supreme Court of Korea argues that the president, as the sole representative of the American nation and the commander-in-chief, has broad powers and is accountable to the Congress and the people for these powers.
 

Analysis of Actors’ Positions on the Water Governance Network of Zayandeh Rud River Basin: A Focus on Isfahan Province’s Geographic Area

Analysis of Actors’ Positions on the Water Governance Network of Zayandeh Rud River Basin: A Focus on Isfahan Province’s Geographic Area

Volume 26, Issue 2, Summer 2023, Pages 7-33

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2023.172241

Esmaeel Zakeri Mahabadi, Mohammad Reza Yazdani Zazerani, Hananeh Mohamadi Kangarani

Abstract Over the past two decades, the Zayandeh Rud River basin has faced numerous challenges in water resource management, resulting in widespread stakeholder dissatisfaction. In light of governance principles, effective policy-making in this area necessitates an understanding of each actor’s impact on the problem’s various dimensions and their interrelationships. This research aims to determine which actors influence the Zayandeh Rud River basin’s water governance network within Isfahan province’s geographic area and to what extent. Using a governance framework, this paper identifies 21 groups of water actors within the specified geography. Data collection and theoretical saturation were achieved through the analysis of data from 72 research participants using network analysis methods. The research data was analyzed using UCINET software, utilizing structural analysis and value component implementation capabilities, and visualized using NETDRAW software. The results reveal the formation of a unique influence network on water resource management, which is not conducive to optimal water governance. This network comprises a variety of actors with distinct capabilities and behaviors, resulting in specific impacts on water issues.

Content Analysis of “Strategic Studies Quarterly” Papers: A Six-Year Review (2017-2023)

Content Analysis of “Strategic Studies Quarterly” Papers: A Six-Year Review (2017-2023)

Volume 26, Issue 2, Summer 2023, Pages 135-153

https://doi.org/10.22034/srq.2023.177554

Morad Shamsi

Abstract This research aims to review and evaluate the form and content of papers published in “Strategic Studies Quarterly”. The study employs a qualitative, content analysis-based methodology and a descriptive-analytical approach to assess the contents. The research population consists of 178 papers published between issue 75 (Spring 2017) and issue 98 (January 2023). To objectively and qualitatively assess the contents, the review was conducted systematically using eleven parameters. The results reveal that the papers can be classified into three general categories related to Iran’s security: 65 papers pertain to internal security, 38 to external security, and 39 to both internal and external security. The evaluation of participant numbers was favorable, with 131 researchers contributing to the writing of 142 papers. Among scientific institutions, Tehran University had the highest contribution with 32 papers. An examination of research methods revealed that the descriptive-analytical method was the most popular among researchers. In terms of the level of analysis, the national level accounted for the largest share of papers at 47.18%.

Chaos Theory and Explanation Requirements in Security Analysis Process

Chaos Theory and "Explanation" Requirements in Security Analysis Process

Volume 22, Issue 83, Spring 2019, Pages 7-32

mirqasem banihashemi, Nourollah Nourani

Abstract This article seeks to obtain the principles and requirements of the explanation stage in the security analysis process based on the theoretical coordinates of chaos theory. This objective is accomplished through answering the following questions: What are the epistemic foundations and conceptual and theoretical principles of chaos theory? And what are the epistemic and methodological requirements of the explanation process within the framework of chaos theory? According to the theoretical and epistemic principles of chaos theory, the explanation stage should take shape based on the principles of "systemic recognition", "importance of internal relations between components at a proper temporal and spatial scale", "unbalanced component effect", "sensitivity to initial conditions", and "short-term forecast window" and should identify and explain the cause of the occurrence of a phenomenon. 
 
 

Discourse of Moderation and National Security in Islamic Republic of Iran (2013-2017)

Discourse of Moderation and National Security in Islamic Republic of Iran (2013-2017)

Volume 22, Issue 83, Spring 2019, Pages 33-72

alireza rahimi

Abstract The discourse of the 11th administration has taken shape based on the noble concept of "moderation" and its components include an interactive approach to the outside world, a moderate interaction model inside the country, an Iranian-Islamic model of development, a broad non-securitized model in the social field, non-mechanical cultural engineering, a combined-local-economic approach to national security with software orientation, creating a promotional model of the Islamic Republic, and a cultural approach to the fight against imperialism. Studies show that the moderation discourse has been effective in the fields of military security, political security, and social cohesion; has had a dual outcome in the area of economic security; and has a long way to achieve the stated goals in the field of environmental security despite some accomplishments.