Volume & Issue: Volume 29, Issue 2 - Serial Number 112, Summer 2026, Pages 11-220 
Number of Articles: 2
<span>The Principle of Preserving the System and Defining the Referent Object of Security in the Islamic States Security Governance: Levels and Priorities</span>

The Principle of Preserving the System and Defining the Referent Object of Security in the Islamic State's Security Governance: Levels and Priorities

Pages 55-79

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2026.576389.4370

Rasoul Hakami Shalamzari

Abstract Introduction Security governance is an emerging subject in contemporary security studies. It has evolved beyond the traditional conceptual framework of security to encompass a broader understanding of both the referent object of security and the actors involved. The concept now encompasses three interrelated dimensions: the referent object of security, security actors, and the processes through which security is provided. Of these, the referent object of security has logical and ontological primacy. Identifying what is to be protected provides the starting point for security policymaking and shapes the actions and institutional mechanisms through which security is pursued. Unless the object of protection is clearly defined, it is impossible to identify relevant threats, determine which actors have legitimate authority, or design appropriate security arrangements. The Islamic state is founded on Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh), which is expected to play a comprehensive role in the governance of human affairs, particularly in the domain of security. This makes it necessary to examine the referent object of security in the Islamic state's system of security governance from a jurisprudential perspective. In Shi‘i jurisprudential thought, matters whose preservation is considered essential to society are addressed under the principle of ḥifẓ al-niẓām (the principle of preserving the system). This principle can take precedence over, or qualify, certain other legal proofs, particularly in matters concerning security measures. In such cases, it may alter the applicable legal ruling or justify actions that would otherwise be deemed impermissible. However, the broad and sometimes insufficiently qualified invocation of this principle to justify or prohibit security measures in the Islamic Republic of Iran makes a more systematic examination necessary. Accordingly, the present study addresses the following question: Given the different levels and meanings of niẓām in political jurisprudence, what criteria determine priorities under the principle of preserving the system, and how does this hierarchy define and prioritize the referent object of security in the security governance of the Islamic state? Methodology This is an applied study based on documentary and library research. Relevant textual sources are collected through electronic databases and library resources and are subsequently subjected to description, analysis, and interpretation. At the analytical stage, an interrogative approach is used to formulate questions that help clarify the issues relevant to the central research question. The study then adopts an objectivist approach to interpretation in order to develop an impartial understanding of the subject. Finally, through contextual interpretation, it examines the historical and textual settings of the relevant sources and seeks to identify the most appropriate answers while avoiding subjective or arbitrary readings of the texts. Findings and Discussion The findings indicate that, in the jurisprudential literature, niẓām as invoked in the principle of preserving the system refers to the protection of the defining foundations and structural integrity of the system at three distinct levels. The Human Social System (the Survival and Stability of Human Society): This is the first level identified in Shi‘i jurisprudential discourse as a referent object of security. It concerns those conditions whose absence, regardless of nationality, race, or other social distinctions, would make the survival of human society impossible or lead to serious disorder in collective life. At this level, the referent object of security is the human being as such, together with the preservation of life and the basic conditions of social order. The primary justification for protecting this level is rational: human reason independently recognizes the disruption of social order as reprehensible and regards efforts to preserve it as commendable. The Islamic System (Islamic Identity): The second level concerns the preservation of Islam itself and the territorial space in which it is established, namely Islamic lands, as well as the integrity and collective existence of the Muslim community, irrespective of nationality or similar distinctions. Its conceptual focus is the Muslim as such and the protection of the Islamic community's religious identity, existence, and territorial integrity. The principal justification for the necessity of preserving this level is a narration attributed to Imam al-Riḍā, the eighth Imam in Twelver Shia Islam, concerning the defense of frontiers. The general scope of the Imam's explanation, which refers to the danger of Islam's gradual decline and eventual disappearance (indirās), indicates that the obligation to preserve Islam is not limited to defending geographical borders.. The Islamic Political System: The third level in this conceptual framework concerns the political system as an established legal institution and governing structure. What distinguishes this level from the two preceding ones is its specific focus on the institution of the state. In the jurisprudential discourse of Shi‘i scholars, the obligation to preserve the political system is not restricted to just governments; it may also extend to unjust forms of rule. This is because, in situations involving existential threats, the survival of the Islamic community may depend on the continuation of a form of government that lacks legitimate authorization. An examination of the relative priority of these three levels, drawing on the distinction between the order of ontological existence and the order of normative obligation, further highlights the central role of the political system in establishing and protecting the other levels. This analysis indicates that, within the security governance framework of the Islamic state, preserving the Islamic political system takes precedence. This prioritization is grounded in the jurisprudential principle of al-ahamm wa al-muhimm (prioritizing the more important over the important), which is supported by both rational and transmitted evidence. The political system serves as the first line of defense in preserving both religion and the human social order. As some jurists have argued, the absence of Islamic government is tantamount to the suspension of Islam itself. Conclusion This study's analysis of the concept of niẓām demonstrates that the referent object of security in the Islamic state is closely linked to the principle of preserving the system in political jurisprudence. In this context, the referent object of security comprises entities and institutions whose continued existence is threatened and whose preservation is legitimately warranted. The study's first theoretical contribution is to establish a precise jurisprudential definition of niẓām. Although the concept encompasses a broad range of objects, the specific legal implications of the principle of preserving the system arise only when the defining foundations and structural integrity of the system are threatened. In other words, this principle can qualify or take precedence over other Islamic legal proofs only when the core or constitutive foundations of the system in question are at risk. Invoking it in circumstances that do not meet this condition is therefore unwarranted. A second contribution is the development of a coherent typology of the levels of security within the framework of security governance. Drawing on the principle of preserving the system in political thought, the study identifies three levels of security: the survival and stability of human society, the preservation of Islamic identity, and the establishment and continuity of political authority. Among these, the preservation and continuity of the political system take priority because of its instrumental character and its functional importance in sustaining the other levels. This hierarchical priority, however, reflects the political system's role in maintaining the broader order; it does not mean that the referent object of security is confined to the political system or that other levels are excluded. Finally, the findings show that the referent object of security in the Islamic state is defined by clear conceptual boundaries without being exclusive in scope. On the one hand, it is not limited to the state and includes the security of citizens. On the other hand, it is not confined to any particular Islamic country but extends to all Islamic states and the Muslim community as a whole. Moreover, by moving beyond a narrowly ideological conception of security, the Islamic state recognizes the human species itself as a referent object of security.

Conceptual Shifts in Cultural Policy (1990–2025): A Scoping Review Focusing on Sensitive Concepts in the Iranian Context

Conceptual Shifts in Cultural Policy (1990–2025): A Scoping Review Focusing on Sensitive Concepts in the Iranian Context

Pages 111-152

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2026.576789.4369

Seyyed Hossein Mousavi, Shahla Bagheri, Soheila - Sadeghi Fassaei, Abolghasem Fatehi - Fatehi

Abstract
Introduction
Over the past three decades, cultural policymaking has undergone significant conceptual changes that have broadened its objectives, expanded the range of actors involved, and diversified its policy instruments. Globalization, advances in communication technologies, the growth of cultural and creative industries, changing governance arrangements, and the increasing involvement of non-state actors have all contributed to this transformation. As a result, cultural policymaking is no longer confined to supporting the arts and preserving cultural heritage. It now encompasses a much wider range of concerns, including identity, participation, network governance, the cultural economy, cultural equity, digital technologies, and cultural resilience.
Despite the growing body of literature on these issues, much of the existing research remains focused on specific policies, national experiences, or particular areas of cultural activity. Studies that provide a comprehensive account of the conceptual evolution of cultural policymaking are still relatively scarce. Persian-language scholarship has likewise concentrated largely on implementation challenges, institutional arrangements, and critical assessments of cultural policy, with limited attention to a systematic review and analysis of conceptual shifts in the international literature. In response to this gap, the present study adopts a scoping review approach to identify, classify, and analyze the conceptual shifts in cultural policymaking between 1990 and 2025. It also examines the role of sensitizing concepts in explaining these shifts and explores how these developments relate to Iranian scholarship.
Methodology
This study employs a scoping review based on the five-stage framework developed by Arksey and O’Malley, following the PRISMA-ScR reporting guidelines. Systematic searches were conducted in Persian-language databases (Noor, Magiran, and SID) and international databases (Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar). The searches used keywords related to cultural policymaking, conceptual shifts, cultural governance, cultural equity, digitalization, and cultural resilience.
Studies were eligible for inclusion if they had been published between 1990 and 2025, addressed the research topic directly, were available in full text, and contained substantive theoretical or analytical material. The initial search identified 165 documents. After approximately 20 duplicates had been removed, title and abstract screening led to the exclusion of around 95 irrelevant documents. Fifty documents were subsequently assessed in full, and one was excluded at the final stage, leaving 49 sources for analysis.
Data were recorded using a structured extraction form and then coded and compared through thematic analysis. Similar concepts were grouped into common categories, leading to the identification of eight conceptual shifts, a set of sensitizing concepts, and approaches specific to the Iranian context. To enhance the reliability of the review, the processes of source selection, data extraction, and conceptual classification were reviewed several times. Generative AI tools were also used in a supporting capacity to assist with data extraction, the organization of data into networks, and the structural cross-checking of references, with the aim of improving technical and editorial accuracy.
Findings and Discussion
The literature on cultural policymaking can be understood through eight major conceptual shifts:

The developmental turn (1970–1980): This phase emphasized an active role for the state, the integration of culture into development strategies, long-term planning, and universal access to cultural resources. Examples include UNESCO’s 1982 initiatives, André Malraux’s cultural policies in France, and the Shiraz Arts Festival.
The market-oriented turn (1980–1990): This shift was characterized by privatization, commercialization, the expansion of cultural and creative industries, and public-private partnerships. Examples include the marketization of the BBC, the Korean Wave, and the growth of private-sector cinema in Iran.
The turn toward the management of identity and meaning (1990s): This phase focused on symbolic capital, cultural heritage, symbolic policymaking, diversity management, and cultural diplomacy. Examples include the Fajr International Film Festival and Canada’s national identity campaign.
The critical and participatory turn (late 1990s–2000s): This approach emphasized cultural democracy, civil society participation, critiques of existing power structures, and bottom-up policymaking. Examples include Brazil’s Culture Points (Pontos de Cultura) program and cultural centers in Iran.
The network governance turn (2005–2010): This shift highlighted networking, the distribution of responsibilities, coordination across different levels of governance, and the state’s role as a facilitator. Examples include the Creative Europe framework and Iran’s Public Culture Council.
The digital and data-driven turn (2010–2015): This phase focused on digital infrastructure, open data, the platform economy, and adaptive policymaking. Examples include the United Kingdom’s Culture is Digital initiative and South Korea’s K-Content strategy.
The cultural resilience turn (2015–2020): This approach emphasized flexible planning, emergency support measures, online innovation, and the involvement of local communities. Examples include virtual ticketing initiatives in Italy, New Zealand’s support package, and online festivals in Iran.
The cultural ethics and equity turn (2020–2025): This shift emphasized inclusive policies, equitable representation, equitable resource allocation, and ethical codes. Examples include the British Film Institute’s (BFI) standards, policies concerning Indigenous cultures in Canada and Māori culture in New Zealand, and rural cultural centers in Iran.

Six sensitizing concepts are particularly important for understanding these shifts. Hegemony (Gramsci and Lears) highlights the role of culture in reproducing power relations. Governmentality (Foucault) frames policymaking as a means of governing and shaping conduct. Resistance (Foucault and Pickett) draws attention to challenges to dominant policies and power structures. Structure of feeling (Williams) emphasize the role of culture in shaping collective emotions and shared experiences. Popular culture (Hall and Fiske) is understood as an arena in which everyday cultural practices may be regulated, contested, or promoted. Finally, taste (Bourdieu) raises questions about the democratization of cultural preferences and judgments.
An examination of indigenous theoretical approaches in Iran reveals six distinct models: the balanced model of the cultural sector; the Sadraean approach; the model of policymaking paradoxes; the framework of national convergence and ethnic diversity management; the social media content model; and the model based on higher-level policy documents. These approaches are largely practical and problem-oriented, and their capacity to provide general theoretical explanations or to be applied across national contexts remains limited.
The overall pattern of conceptual change suggests that the evolution of cultural policymaking has been cumulative and layered. Each shift emerged partly in response to the limitations of earlier approaches, but none entirely displaced what came before. The process is therefore better understood as a change in the primary focus of policymaking than as the wholesale replacement of one paradigm by another.
Conclusion
The conceptual evolution of cultural policymaking from the 1970s to 2025 represents more than a change in policy priorities. It reflects broader transformations in the underlying logic of cultural governance, the roles of different actors, the instruments of policymaking, and its theoretical foundations. The eight shifts identified in this study trace a movement away from predominantly state-centered approaches toward more complex, participatory, and crisis-responsive models, most of which have emerged from Western scholarship. The sensitizing concepts examined here further demonstrate that cultural policymaking is not simply concerned with regulating artistic activities; it also plays a significant role in shaping collective identities, power relations, and forms of social resistance.
In Iran, indigenous approaches have primarily focused on structural paradoxes, fragmented decision-making authority, and the challenges of adapting external models to local conditions. Digitalization and cultural resilience have received comparatively little theoretical attention in domestic scholarship. By contrast, the cultural ethics and equity turn offers considerable potential for further theory-building, given its points of convergence with indigenous and religious values.
Nevertheless, the limited number of in-depth conceptual studies, the predominance of broad ideological perspectives, and the disproportionate emphasis on bureaucratic approaches have created a significant gap in understanding the relationship between official policies and the lived realities of society. One of the most important dimensions of this gap is the contrast between international scholarship, which places greater emphasis on network governance, the participation of non-state stakeholders, and continuous evaluation, and Iranian scholarship, which tends to prioritize the role of the state and top-down policymaking.
The recommendations emerging from this study emphasize the need to adapt global conceptual shifts to the Iranian context. The participatory turn could help broaden citizen involvement in cultural policymaking; the digital turn could provide a framework for addressing the effects of algorithm-driven media on cultural identity; and the resilience and equity turns could contribute to strengthening society’s capacity to withstand crises such as economic sanctions. The study also calls for empirical research into the effects of these shifts on cultural actors, a move toward network-based and participatory policymaking, and the further development of Iranian conceptual scholarship to facilitate more substantive engagement with international literature.
Ultimately, the future development of cultural policymaking depends on bringing together three key elements: preserving cultural identity and indigenous values, expanding social participation and network governance, and making effective use of evidence, data, and emerging technologies. Such an approach would entail a transition toward policymaking that is adaptive, participatory, and subject to continuous evaluation