Keywords = Securitization
Number of Articles: 11
The European Union’s Discursive Policy toward Migrants: A Case Study of Afghan Migrants

The European Union’s Discursive Policy toward Migrants: A Case Study of Afghan Migrants

Volume 29, Issue 1, Summer 2026, Pages 197-231

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2026.568304.4350

Ruhollah Amini, Mokhtar Salehi

Abstract Introduction
The 2015 migration crisis marked a turning point in European Union policymaking, as migration gradually came to be framed not merely as a humanitarian issue but also as a matter with significant security implications. Within this context, the migration of Afghan nationals assumed particular importance in EU migration policy, given the persistence of political instability and the intensification of displacement in Afghanistan, particularly following the Taliban’s return to power in 2021. Despite the significance of this issue, much of the existing literature has focused on the legal, statistical, and administrative dimensions of migration, while comparatively little attention has been devoted to the discursive representation of Afghan migrants in European political and media discourse. Discourse analysis is particularly important because dominant representations of migration are not simply descriptive. They actively contribute to legitimizing policies, shaping institutional priorities, allocating resources, and structuring policy practices.
The central research question is: How has Afghan migration been represented in the political and media discourse of the European Union, and what role have these representations played in shaping EU migration policies? The article argues that Afghan migration has largely been represented through a multilayered process of securitization in which security-oriented, technocratic, and humanitarian rationalities operate simultaneously.
Methodology
The study adopts an analytical-critical approach based on the Copenhagen School’s theory of securitization and Norman Fairclough’s three-dimensional model of critical discourse analysis, which examines discourse at the textual, discursive, and social levels. In contrast to state-centric approaches, the Copenhagen School conceptualizes security not as an objective condition but as a discursive and intersubjective phenomenon produced through linguistic and political interactions. The concept of securitization, developed by Ole Wæver, refers to the process through which issues that would ordinarily be addressed through routine political processes are constructed as matters of existential urgency. Through this process, an issue is represented discursively as a threat to survival, thereby legitimizing the adoption of extraordinary measures.
The empirical data consist of three main categories: official EU documents, including European Commission communications, statements, and policy frameworks; reports issued by the European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Frontex), the EU agency responsible for supporting border management and security; and selected media texts from The Guardian, POLITICO Europe, and Kathimerini. The analysis covers the period from 2015 to 2025. Approximately 80 institutional and media texts were analyzed using NVivo through a combination of theory-driven and data-driven coding. The resulting concepts were organized into three principal conceptual clusters: securitization, rights-based discourse, and technocratic discourse.
Findings and Discussion
The findings indicate that EU migration policy toward Afghan migrants has been shaped by three major discursive patterns.
Securitization Discourse
Following the 2015 migration crisis, EU migration policymaking was reconfigured in ways that increasingly framed migration through security and managerial lenses. The use of terms such as “crisis,” “influx,” and “illegal crossing” in official discourse contributed to shifting migration from the domain of routine policymaking into a sphere of urgency. In Frontex reports, Afghan migration, alongside migration from Syria and the Sahel region, is represented as a challenge to the effective functioning of the EU’s border-management system. Terms such as “threat,” “disorder,” “smuggling,” and “migratory pressure” also recur frequently in these reports.
The Threat-Victim Dichotomy
EU migration policies toward Afghan migrants have been articulated within a persistent tension between rights-based and security-oriented discourses. While official documents emphasize the EU’s moral responsibility and its commitment to protecting asylum seekers, migration is simultaneously represented as a potential source of social instability and a challenge to domestic order. This dual representation serves an important political function. Representing migrants as victims allows the EU to preserve its commitment to human rights and humanitarian values, while their simultaneous representation as potential threats reinforces the legitimacy of restrictive and control-oriented migration policies.
Technocratic and Bureaucratic Discourse
Alongside these securitizing processes, another layer of discourse has emerged that is predominantly technical, managerial, and bureaucratic in character. Within this framework, migration is treated primarily as an operational and data-driven policy problem, while concepts such as “risk management,” “security screening,” and “surveillance systems” have become increasingly prominent in the policy lexicon. The substantial increase in Frontex’s budget, from €535 million in 2021 to €845 million in 2023, provides a clear indication of the institutional and structural consolidation of this discourse.
In contrast, a rights-based and humanitarian discourse, articulated by civil society organizations such as the European Council on Refugees and Exiles (ECRE) and Amnesty International, as well as by liberal media outlets such as The Guardian, emphasizes human dignity, humanitarian protection, and moral responsibility. These narratives, however, have generally remained peripheral to the dominant policy discourse, although at certain critical junctures they have influenced official decision-making. For example, the Afghanistan Country Guidance issued by the European Union Agency for Asylum (EUAA) in 2024, drawing on evidence of widespread repression in Afghanistan, recognized the need for international protection for a broad range of Afghan asylum seekers.
Conclusion
The study demonstrates that, between 2015 and 2025, security-oriented discourse played a decisive role in shaping EU migration policies toward Afghan migrants. Discursive representations did not merely describe migration; they actively contributed to making particular policy responses possible and to legitimizing them. The construction of Afghan migration as a security threat helped create the political and institutional conditions for increased funding and expanded powers for Frontex, more extensive security screening procedures, and the institutionalization of return policies.
The study’s principal theoretical contribution lies in proposing a three-layer typology of the securitization of Afghan migration: classical institutional securitization, technocratic-bureaucratic securitization, and conditional humanitarian securitization. This typology challenges a common assumption in the securitization literature that securitization necessarily occurs through an explicit speech act and the declaration of a state of exception. The findings suggest that, in contemporary EU migration policy, securitization can also become embedded through the normalized language of policymaking, the bureaucratization of decision-making, and the simultaneous operation of security and humanitarian rationalities.
Methodologically, the combination of the Copenhagen School’s securitization theory with Fairclough’s model of critical discourse analysis demonstrates that the securitization of Afghan migrants is not solely the outcome of explicit political decisions. Rather, it can gradually become institutionalized through normalized policy language, bureaucratic practices, and media representations. The findings also offer practical guidance for migration policymaking in Iran, one of the principal host countries for Afghan migrants. They suggest that an exclusively security-oriented approach, although potentially effective in strengthening administrative controls in the short term, may in the longer term contribute to greater social marginalization and make migration governance more complex and difficult.

Understanding the Relationship between Social and Security Issues from the Perspectives of Modern and Postmodern Paradigms: A Focus on the Ideas of Émile Durkheim and Jacques Derrida

Understanding the Relationship between Social and Security Issues from the Perspectives of Modern and Postmodern Paradigms: A Focus on the Ideas of Émile Durkheim and Jacques Derrida

Volume 28, Issue 1, Summer 2025, Pages 115-139

https://doi.org/10.22034/ssq.2025.500724.4248

Nurullah nourani, Ali Alaei

Abstract Introduction
Understanding and addressing social and security issues today requires a deep and fundamental theoretical analysis based on dominant paradigms. This paper focuses on the ideas of Émile Durkheim and Jacques Derrida to compare how social and security issues are viewed from modern and postmodern paradigms. The main goal is to explore how social problems turn into security crises and to examine how these issues are understood, explained, and addressed within the frameworks of these two distinguished thinkers. This study also aims to offer a combined model that can be useful for current security policymaking.
Methodology
The study employs a qualitative method with a comparative and discourse analysis approach. Key concepts such as order, threat, cohesion, exclusion, and insecurity are explored through the works of Durkheim and Derrida. The analysis is structured around three steps—identifying, explaining, and addressing —to better understand the connection between social and security issues in both modern and postmodern paradigms. The main data comes from classic texts in sociology and political philosophy, analyzed conceptually.
Discussion and Results
According to Durkheim, social problems become security crises when social institutions fail to perform their roles and social cohesion weakens. Therefore, security depends on institutional order and social solidarity. His solutions focus on gradually reforming economic structures and strengthening intermediate institutions. On the other hand, Derrida sees security as a fluid, language-based, and discursive construct that is constantly reshaped through interaction with the Other and opposing categories like safe/risky. He warns that excessive securitization can lead to excluding others, structural violence, and creating more insecurity. Derrida’s method of deconstruction helps reveal contradictions within dominant discourses and exposes how exclusion and power operate in security processes. In short, Durkheim emphasizes objectivity and institution, while Derrida rethinks security in terms of meaning, difference, and accepting the Other.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that combining Durkheim’s and Derrida’s perspectives provides a comprehensive framework for analyzing security and shaping policies. Durkheim focuses on the function of social institutions and economic reform, while Derrida highlights the need to rethink closed security discourses and be open to differences and otherness. Together, their views offer policymakers a flexible, justice-oriented strategy for dealing with social and security challenges. Finally, the study stresses the importance of avoiding unnecessary securitization, accepting ontological insecurity, and building resilient social institutions to ensure sustainable security.

Nordic Securitization Model: Transition of Environment from securitizing to Normalizing

Nordic Securitization Model: Transition of Environment from securitizing to Normalizing

Volume 22, Issue 86, Winter 2020, Pages 123-150

Reza Rahmati

Abstract Securitization is depended to the context of the “Security Problem”. Transition of the environment from a normal issue to the political and security ones has made Nordic's security model as a new model. The research hypothesis is that the environmental threats in the Nordic have first transitioned from the public Sphere (the normal) into the political and security Sphere and then, through the four processes of security policy-making, security strategy, political capital, and actors' consensus become a part of the social life of citizens.
 

Saudi Arabias role in Securitization of Iran; The Islamic Republic of Iran Strategy

Saudi Arabia's role in Securitization of Iran; The Islamic Republic of Iran Strategy

Volume 22, Issue 85, Winter 2020, Pages 83-106

Aliakbar Asadi

Abstract  
The purpose of the article is to examine King Salman of Saudi Arabia's approach towards Iran and the strategy of the Islamic Republic of Iran against Saudi actions. This paper hypothesizes that Saudi Arabia under King Salman has more than ever attempted to securitization of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the role of "functional actor". The main finding of this article is that support for securitization of Iran's regional role in the Middle East has been a key focus of Malik Salman's Saudi policy toward Iran. The new Saudi leaders have emphasized on what they called "Iran's destructive regional role" and tried to highlight Iran's policies and actions in the Middle East as the main threat to regional stability and security to mobilize various capacities against Iran. Although these measures have exacerbated security pressures against the Islamic Republic of Iran, however, trying to securitization of Iran has faced significant restrictions and challenges.
 

Correlation Between the Islamic Republic of Irans Political Identity and the U.S. as an Enemy

Correlation Between the Islamic Republic of Iran's Political Identity and the U.S. as an Enemy

Volume 21, Issue 80, Summer 2018, Pages 55-74

Alireza Khosravi

Abstract Following the victory of the Islamic Revolution and the hostage crisis, a new entity, that is the United States as an enemy, became one of the most revealing and consolidating aspects of the political identity of the Islamic Republic of Iran's establishment. With a focus on the role of political identity, this article seeks to answer the question why the Islamic Republic of Iran still insists on not having relations with the United States and refuses to make compromises with it despite all the US-led structural pressure now that four decades have passed since the victory of the revolution. The views of political realists have been used to answer this question. Political realists maintain that the friend-enemy distinction is the essence and core tenet of politics. They also argue that the strong and innate need of groups and entities to maintain a political identity rather than a structure or a desire for power underlies this distinction and emphasize the need to keep a distance from the enemy in order to survive and pursue own objectives.

Transatlantic Convergence and Divergence on Securitization of Islamic Republic of Iran: Trends and Patterns

Transatlantic Convergence and Divergence on Securitization of Islamic Republic of Iran: Trends and Patterns

Volume 21, Issue 79, Spring 2018, Pages 121-144

Mohammad Reza Takhshid, Azizollah Hatamzadeh

Abstract This article explores the underlying factors behind the convergence and divergence of views of the United States and Europe on the Islamic Republic of Iran. In addition to investigating past trends and experiences, the authors have put forward the theory that the extent of divergence and convergence of the US and Europe on Iran depends on the level of Washington's success in presenting the Islamic Republic as a security threat to Europe. The more success the US has achieved in this regard, the closer their views have been on the Islamic Republic. Similarities in strategies and policies adopted by Europe and the US, the alliance between their leaders, the extent to which they approve of each other's policies under different administrations and the Islamic Republic of Iran's foreign policy are factors which determine whether Europe would align itself with the US that could eventually lead to either a transatlantic divergence or convergence on Iran. 

The Religious Zionism and its Strategic Role in Israel’s Foreign Policy

The Religious Zionism and its Strategic Role in Israel’s Foreign Policy

Volume 17, Issue 66, Summer 2014, Pages 129-160

Mahdi Ahouie

Abstract Although the Israeli government has a secular nature, Zionism is increasingly prevailing its internal and external affairs. Using the theory of securitization, the paper addresses religious Zionism orientation, as belief of minority but with strong voice, of the Israeli government with increasing status which in turn is a result of identity crisis and security vulnerabilities; so it has been the dominant and comprehensive discourse of the country and has been successfully radicalized its foreign policy. In this way, Netanyahu's administration has been opposing establishing a Palestinian government and increased pace settlements with no restrain from use of violence against the defenseless people of Palestine. Implementing this policy, Israel is not taking peace lover position anymore and has adopted an intrusive approach against its peripheral environment.  Although this policy may lead to more convergence in short term in Israel, however, in midterm, it can result in more isolation and vulnerability of Israel.  

Threatening effects of Missile defense shield extension on I.R. Iran’s national security

Threatening effects of Missile defense shield extension on I.R. Iran’s national security

Volume 17, Issue 65, Summer 2014, Pages 101-134

Naseraldin Heydari

Abstract Containing I.R. Iran’s missile capabilities is an immediate goal in U.S.A missile defense approach in Obama administration. Iran’s access to missile and satellite technology (manufacturing and launching) is deemed as a threat for U.S.A and southern neighbors of Persian Gulf, so the mission of missile defense shield is to contain and counter Iran’s capabilities in missile and satellite fields. This article  based on offensive and defensive realism , analyses security challenges emerging from extension of missile defense shield for I.R. Iran  and regarding emergency of this threats for Iran, proposes to intensify interactions and defense diplomacy with southern neighbors based on self-restraint and moderation to strengthen Iran’s national security.  

Theoretical reflection on findings and difficulties of Barry Buzan in security studies

Theoretical reflection on findings and difficulties of "Barry Buzan" in security studies

Volume 14, Issue 54, Winter 2012, Pages 105-134

Gadir Nasri

Abstract Abstract: the main problem of this article is to analyze findings and difficulties of Barry Buza's researches in security studies. The question of article is: what is the role of Buzan in development of security studies and what are his theories paradoxes and ambiguities? Author assumes some ambiguities and paradoxes in Buzan thoughts and  his hypothesis is that, Buzan has developed security studies by proposing the need to pass from strategic studies to security studies, emphasizing on social/political aspects of security, and specially discussing mysterious nature of security in international system. Meanwhile Buzan's arguments and conclusions about societal security, source of security, regional level of analysis, and securitization/de-securitization weakens validity and generalizations of his findings.  Methodology of this research is "text based hermeneutics. According to this method, we first explain the theory and then criticize it.

Aspects and impacts of Irans risky geopolitics

Aspects and impacts of Iran's risky geopolitics

Volume 14, Issue 54, Winter 2012, Pages 163-192

Seyed masood mosavi shafaee, Mahdi shapoori

Abstract Abstract:  this article uses the concept of "risky geopolitics" to explain security threats and their consequences, emanating from foreign environment of Islamic republic of Iran. Author argues that securitization of Iran's peripheral environment after Islamic revolution, is effect of geopolitical changes. According to the argument, factors like peak oil production, emergence of Shiite geopolitics, terrorism in Middle East, continuation of arab-israeli conflict and nuclear Middle East, are causes of securitization and geopolitical threat against Iranian national security. Authors claim that these factors have close relations and are interconnected in Iran environment. Impacts of this situation are Isolation, sanction and threat of resorting to military action from great powers, especially United States.

Criticizing the Theory of Securitization

Criticizing the Theory of Securitization

Volume 9, Issue 33, Autumn 2006, Pages 491-512

Ali Abdollahkhani

Abstract     Theory of securitization was produced by Copenhagen school for analyzing the security problems. According the Speech Act conception, this theory by focus on linguistic analysis of security argues that it would be just appeared when expressed. The theory by designing actor, context and audience does discuss about the security problems. As matter of fact, the theory enjoys from constructive and realistic epistemology. Here the purpose of this paper is discussing and examining this theory by making some questions such as what's security, who's the securitizing actor, in which condition the problem may be concept as a security problem and what the proper time of securitizing the phenomena is. And also, this article from critique stand bring up six objects related to the theory such as exclusivities and anxiety, the strategic speech act, what kind of action, which type of threat, succession, and security: self – objectification. After all the theory the more is a managing theory than the analytical or appraisal one, because of it focus on how could be managing better the security sphere.